Baasit Kazi
Ms. Bogert
College Accounting 1-1B
28 April, 2015
Accounting Scandals Reflection
Enron was founded in July of 1985. Enron was an electricity and natural gas company which was a fortune 500 company and it was ranked the sixth largest energy company in the world. Enron’s stock went from a peak of $90.75 to $0.67. This was very detrimental to stockholders. Enron’s top executives sold their stock a long time before the stock price fell. A lot of lower level employees could not sell their stock because of deals they made with the company. This later caused a lot of these employees to lose their life savings and everything they had worked for. Enron used a very complex accounting method to trick the stock market. This method was called “mark to market” accounting. Enron used this method of accounting to predict and project their earnings in a long term period. These earnings were projected based on the long term energy contracts Enron was going to make. This could have been money that was not made at that point. This made Enron’s stock price skyrocket at a very fast pace, making a lot of employees and general public invest in the stock. Enron stock seemed to be a very secure and profitable investment which would make people lots of money. The Fortune 500 company went down very quickly. In August of 2001, the CEO of Enron, Jeffrey Skilling resigned. He randomly resigned and a lot of suspicions arose. His resignation was described to be because of personal reasons.
Enron had the largest bankruptcy in America’s history and it happened in less than a year because of scandals and manipulation Enron displayed with California’s energy supply. A few years ago, Enron was the world’s 7th largest corporation, valued at 70 billion dollars. At that time, Enron’s business model was full of energy and power. Ken Lay and Jeff Skilling had raised Enron to stand on a culture of greed, lies, and fraud, coupled with an unregulated accounting system, which caused Enron to go down. Lies were being told by top management to the government, its employees and investors. There was a rise in Enron 's share price because of pyramid scheme; their strategy consisted of claiming so much money to easily get away with their tricky ways. They deceived their investors so they could keep investing their money in the company.
Jumping right into the summary then. Enron was one of the most successful corporations in America during its prime. Marketing electricity and other commodities, as well as, providing financial and risk management services to other companies were the main types of business that Enron conducted. However, Enron’s successful appearance was found out to be a façade, when it came out that the corporation was making a plethora of unethical business moves. Once the corporation’s actions became public, Enron’s fall from grace quickly followed. (Johnson, 2003)
In 2001, Enron, the largest energy company in the U.S., collapsed after a vast creative-accounting scandal. Enron practiced a type of accounting called mark-to-market practice which it used to hide losses. Mark-to-market accounting it not illegal on its own but it was used improperly by Enron. The CFO and CEO of Enron were able to write off any losses to an off-the-book balance sheet and made the company appear financially healthy (Seabury, 2008). Investors lost $74 billion while thousands of employees lost their jobs and
What did Enron buy and sell? Electricity? Natural gas? The corporation created a market in energy, gambled in it and manipulated it. It moved on into other futures markets, even seriously considering "trading weather." At one point, we learn, its gambling traders lost the entire company in bad trades, and covered their losses by hiding the news and producing phony profit reports that drove the share price even higher. Enron was a corporation devoted to maintaining a high share price at any cost. How Wall Street and the bankers wanted to investigate if they are the first to get profit from all that.
On the surface, the motives behind decisions and events leading to Enron’s downfall appear simple enough: individual and collective greed born in an atmosphere of market euphoria and corporate arrogance. Hardly anyone—the company, its employees, analysts or individual investors—wanted to believe the company was too good to be true. So, for a while, hardly anyone did. Many kept on buying the stock, the corporate mantra and the dream. In the meantime, the company made many high-risk deals, some of which were outside the company’s typical asset risk control process. Many went sour in the early months of 2001 as Enron’s stock price and debt rating imploded because of
Enron was founded by Ken Lay in 1985 as a result of a merger of two gas companies. Enron was in top fortune 500 at number 7 and could not produce accurate financial statements to their investors. Top executives sold over a billion dollars in personal stock two years prior to their demise. Thousands of employees lost their jobs and. Author Anderson shredded all the financial statements all in one day. Employees of Enron lost over a billion and retirement and pension. Many of the top executives got off with just a slap on the wrist. The Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 was set into place to make sure financial organizations are honest with investors.
Enron shocked the world from being “America’s most innovative company” to America 's biggest corporate bankruptcy at its time. At its peak, Enron was America 's seventh largest corporation. Enron gave the illusion that it was a steady company with good revenue but that was not the case, a large part of Enron’s profits were made of paper. This was made possible by masterfully designed accounting and morally questionable acts by traders and executives.
The company Enron was formed in 1985 after two natural gas companies, Houston Natural Gas and InterNorth merged together. Kenneth Lay, former chief executive officer of Houston Natural Gas was named CEO of Enron and a year later, Lay was assigned to the chairman of Enron. A few years later, Enron launched a website to allow customers to buy stock for Enron, making it the largest business site in the world. The growth of Enron was rapid; it was even named seventh largest company on the Fortune 500 list; however things began to fall apart in 2001. (News, 2006). In the third quarter of that same year, Enron posted an enormous loss of over $600 million in four years. This is one of the reasons why one of the top executive resigned even though he had only after six months on the job. Their stock prices fell dramatically. Eventually, Enron filed for bankruptcy protection. This caused many investors to lose money they had invested in the company and employees to lose their jobs and their investments, including their retirement funds. The filing of bankruptcy and the resignation of one of the top executives, also led to an investigation by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Committee, which proved to be one of the biggest scandals in U.S. history. (News, 2006). All former senior executives stood trial for their illegal practices.
All of the prior represents the business side of the downfall of Enron. That being said, businesses fail all of the time. The reason why Enron Corporation and its executives will always live in infamy is not because the company failed, but how and why the company failed. How, exactly, does a company worth about $70 million collapse in less than a month? It became clear that the company not only had financial problems, but ethical problems that started from the top of the company and trickled down. A key player in these problems was Jeffrey Skilling. He was a man brought to the company by Ken Lay himself. Skilling brought his own accounting concept to the company. It was called mark-to-market accounting. This concept allowed Enron to record potential profits the day a deal was signed. This meant that the company could report whatever they “thought” profits from the deal were going to be and count the number towards actual profits, even if no money actually came in. Mark-to-market accounting granted Enron the power to report major profits to the public, even if they were little or even negative. It became a major way
Based on the documentary, Enron: Smartest Guys in the Room, it is proven that the company's financial condition was nothing but a creatively planned accounting fraud. The approved legislation of deregulating the sale of natural gas has results in markets which made it possible for traders to sell it at higher prices, therefore significantly increasing revenue. After Jeffrey Skilling was hired, by using accounting loopholes and poor financial reporting, it was able to hide billions of dollars of debt from failed deals and projects. The deregulating of market and establishing numerous limited liabilities allowed Enron to hide its company's liabilities from appearing in accounts, thus allowing it to generally increase stock prices and keep its
In this research paper I will be examining accounting scandals, specifically the Enron Accounting Scandal. First, I will be exploring the history of Enron. Then I will be going into further depth on what accounting issues Enron faced and then I will be explaining what a derivative is. Finally yet importantly, I will consider the different types of Accounting Fraud following a conclusion. Accounting Scandals are born due to collective greed and corporate arrogance. In the case of Enron there was a lot of euphoria before the downfall. Stock prices soared and Enron was seen as one of the most innovative companies in the world. However, things seemed too good to be true. Eventually the company was exposed for its wrongdoing which led to the collapse. Many more of such cases were exposed during the 2008/2009 recession such as the Lehmann Brothers scandal. As mentioned earlier, many financial scandals have happened in the past but none of those are nearly as bad as the scandals when it gets to trading in derivatives.
Enron's entire scandal was based on a foundation of lies characterized by the most brazen and most unethical accounting and business practices that will forever have a place in the hall of scandals that have shamed American history. To the outside, Enron looked like a well run, innovative company. This was largely a result of self-created businesses or ventures that were made "off the balance sheet." These side businesses would sell stock, reporting profits, but not reporting losses. "Treating these businesses "off the balance sheet" meant that Enron pretended that these businesses were autonomous, separate firms. But, if the new business made money, Enron would report it as income. If the new business lost money or borrowed money, the losses and debt were not reported by Enron" (mgmtguru.com). As the Management Guru website explains, these tactics were alls designed to make Enron look like a more profitable company and to give it a higher stock price.
Enron was formed in July 1985 by the merger of InterNorth and Houston Natural Gas (Enron Fast Facts, 2015). Kenneth Lay became chief executive of Enron and he hired Jeffrey Skilling to look after the company’s energy trading operation (The rise and fall of Enron, 2006). Skilling’s plan was to be basically a gas bank where buys gas from suppliers for future years at previously agreed prices and sells the gas to its customers in advance to purchase at specified prices for future years. By doing that, Enron was able to make money just as a bank would (Thomas, 2002). After seeing the successful results, there was a new division managed by Skilling, Enron Finance created in 1990 to begin selling financial instruments. Enron next step was Enron Online divisions and again it was overnight success and handled $335 billion in online commodity trades in 2000 (Thomas, 2002). Enron used a practice known as “mark-to-market” to report for its book and mark-to-market accounting requires to revalue assets on the balance sheet that respond to the increased or decreased market value and reports the difference as profit or loss on the income statement (Thomas, 2002). Taking this as its advantage, Enron recognized profits on its futures that intended to be sold 20 to 30 years later with the price that is impossible to estimate and record the unreliable profits on its income statement.
Enron executives and accountants cooked the books and lied about the financial state of the company. They manipulated the earnings and booked revenue that never came in. This was encouraged by Ken Lay as long as the company was making money. Once word got out that they were disclosing this information, their stock plummeted from $90 to $0.26 causing the corporation to file for bankruptcy.
The first failure of Enron is that it lacked a solid accounting information system. Instead, the firm adopted a concept called mark to market. This is where all accounting records of a company’s assets were based on the prevailing market price. The failure of this system is that it allows the accountants to record the value of the assets and liabilities at any value. This orchestrates mass cover ups and conspiracy as revenues will be based on speculation and derivatives. In the end the financial statements produced are highly in accurate and do not show the true position of a corporation. For instance, through this accounting system Enron was able to show that its revenues were growing while in fact the revenues were non-existent in the first place. A good case in point is the offshore partnerships opened by the CFO Andrew Fastow, and Enron official. The strategic offshore partnerships were used by Enron to project revenues that were reported in the company’s financial statements (Seabury, n.d). Other deals such as the blockbuster live streaming movie using bandwidth technology was used to inflate the revenues of the company by recording projected revenues from such deals. In return, financial analysts gave the company’s stock a higher rating based on projected revenues and derivatives. This explains why Enron was the golden goose for Wall Street prior to its collapse. From the above analysis it is apparent that the accounting information