preview

Advantages And Disadvantages Of Enhancing Competency In English

Decent Essays

The grammar debate has been around for decades. In the article of ‘Enhancing Competency in English’, Shah has explained about the advantages and disadvantages of both covert approach and overt approach in a very precise and thorough way. On the other hand, Wilson, in ‘Testing the Covert Method of Grammar Teaching’, advocated the usage of covert approach in teaching grammar by conducting a survey on learners’ interest. In ‘To Grammar or Not to Grammar’, Weaver, McNally and Moerman have discussed about the methods and stages in implementing the application of approaches. In addition, the article of ‘Teaching Grammar in Context’ by Mart advocated the notion of using context-based grammar in teaching grammar effectively.
Approaches in the Teaching of Grammar
Overt approach is very handy when it comes to introducing the function of the text, system and linguistics structure in English Language. In ‘Enhancing Competency in English’, Shah stated that overt approach is essential in promoting learners’ awareness of grammar rules in English language. Shah (2015) has defined overt approach as ‘Overt approach is a process of dividing the whole parts of speech into manageable bite size chunks and then introduces these to the students (p.).
In addition, he also proposed that overt approach that highlighted on drilling has benefited pupils in the examination. From the article, it stated pupils need to comprehend and master the rules explicitly as it could help them in answering the question. However, this might not be true as marks in examination are mostly allocated on writing skills. Through overt approach, pupils will only be able …show more content…

However, there is no clear guideline on when to use which approach in the articles. Therefore, teachers should make the choice of approach by determining the ultimate needs of

Get Access