preview

Analysis Of The 491st Sin In Wuthering Heights

Good Essays

The 491st sin, or the failure to listen, is considered to be the unforgivable sin. In Wuthering Heights, a novel written by Emily Brontë, Mr. Lockwood comes to Thrushcross Grange to learn a lesson about love and listening. While staying there, Lockwood learns the stories of many characters as lessons on refraining to commit the 491st sin. Catherine Earnshaw Linton has the most to teach him about this lesson. Nelly, while able to teach Lockwood valuable lessons about listening, fails to teach him as much as Catherine. Nelly never listened to the consequences of her actions. Living in a time period where women had close to no rights or power, Nelly tries to gain some power through keeping information from others. For example, when …show more content…

While she is “...passing harsh judgment on my many derelictions of duty; from which, it struck me then, all the misfortunes of my employers sprang. It was not the case, in reality…” (267). Nelly doesn’t learn from her own mistakes, and when something isn’t learned, it can’t be taught by that person. Therefore, Nelly, being the narrator, may have a lesson helpful to Lockwood, but her ignorance from not listening to the consequences of her actions keep her from being able to teach Lockwood through telling the story. Hindley, while having a lot to teach Lockwood on the failure to listen, does not have the most to teach him. He ignores the truth and advice coming from other people, which leads him to become a drunken fool. When Nelly asks Hindley about “‘the mistress… the doctor says she’s----’ ‘Damn the doctor!’ he interrupted, reddening” (64). Hindley doesn’t listen to the truth, that his wife is going to die, choosing instead to believe in a lie that she will get better. This sets him up for failure when Frances does pass away. Nelly notes that Hindley only has room for himself and his wife in his heart, and when she passes, it will be devastating for Hindley. When Frances does die, Hindley does fall from grace, becoming a heavy drinker who curses out all. However, until the bitter end, Hindley never listened to the advice of others. Even when Nelly says, “‘Nay, don’t!’ I entreated. ‘Mr. Hindley, do take

Get Access