preview

Comparison Of The Article 'Dignity And Dreams'

Decent Essays

Introduction The question of concern in the article, Dignity and Dreams (Sykes, 2015), was whether the Earned Income Tax Credit [EITC] provided families with enough support to progress financially just over the poverty line. While This was an important focus there was a The emphasis on how the family respectfully and discreetly received the money was also an active factor. Likewise, in the second article, Bonus or Rebate? (Epley, 2006), there was a concern about a consumer’s reluctant choice to spend a check depending on its label. They specifically tracked spending patterns of consumers receiving either a Rebate (a loss) check or a bonus (a gain) check and documented whether they spent a larger portion of the check or saved more of it. …show more content…

Or would the recipients spend a surplus of money if thought to be a bonus check? Sykes (2015) had found that families felt a relief from financial stress when it came to receiving their yearly lump sum from the government. They were able to pay back many of their debts, just as a responsible family should. This allowed them to enhance the amount of consumption they were given leeway for. Such as toys or brand name foods. For families in Welfare who were given limited room to grow, EITC left enough money to lift dreams off the ground and making it possible for families to invest in their futures. All of these factors made it easier for the families to feel a sense of citizenship. Social inclusion plays a larger factor than once thought. Using government programs like SNAP (food stamps) ostracized people in public areas; making it difficult to feel proud or in a sense “normal”. I strongly believe that this article found what they set out to look for. The results clearly show that EITC gave low wage families a sense of dignity, but since the population interviewed and tracked was so small it’s difficult to believe that all families in the same program live entirely the same. The lurking variables consisted of past programs impeding on the behavior of present recipients in the EITC program. These past programs have altered the way of thinking for some people. The

Get Access