preview

Argumentative Essay On SAT Testing

Decent Essays

SAT Testing: Death to All Students
Nearly half of Penn State freshman that may be seen on the first day, will not be there through the first semester. 46 percent of college freshmen drop out of college their first year (Higgins). Why are nearly half of all students dropping out, when in order to be accepted they had to meet ‘college readiness benchmarks’? One of the most well-known benchmarks is the SAT. In fact, 1.7 million students took the SAT in 2015, which is higher from the previous year of 1.67 million (Adams). These numbers are very large due to the fact that most colleges and universities require students to send their scores as part of the application process. Although most require SAT scores to be admitted, SAT scores are unnecessary …show more content…

If this is true and GPA and school activity involvement are more important, then why is the SAT even considered? Brandon Busteed, an executive director of Gallup Education, ran a study including 2,586 superintendents around his area. According to his results, “...Only six percent of superintendents strongly agree that SAT and ACT scores are the best predictors of college success” (Brandon Busteed). This shows that even educators feel that the SAT lacks a true purpose. How can any college determine a student's study habits, work ethic, or community involvement through a number? Jennifer Finney Boylan, a professor at Colby College, states, “The only way to measure students’ potential is to look at the complex portrait of their lives; what their schools are like; how they’ve done in their courses; what they’ve chosen to study; what progress they’ve made over time; how they’ve reacted to adversity” (Hambrick & Chabris). Although other factors are not ignored, including involvement and high school GPA, there is still immense pressure to do well on the SATs. Busteed states, “We’re not just overinvesting in standardized testing, we’re actually testing standardization. That is to say, most standardized tests are designed to have students come up with the same answers. We’re teaching them how to be similar, not different” (2015). This shows the negative effects that the SAT has on …show more content…

A college as early as 2008 began to follow their results as to eliminating SAT scores. Their director of admissions, Ann B. McDermott, speaks out about the positive changes its testing optional policy has created. “...After three years of an SAT-optional policy, Holy Cross has become more geographically and ethnically diverse as well as more selective in admissions… Students are the beneficiaries of this change in policy because they are rewarded for good choices and habits throughout their high school career, and not judged on the basis of a single test” (2012). Without SAT score requirements, Holy Cross has seen many more applicants who might have shied away from applying because their scores did not fit the average, and more diversity is prevalent as well (McDermott). With such positive outcomes from just one college, one can only imagine if all colleges made SAT scores optional in

Get Access