preview

Benigni's Life Is Beautiful

Decent Essays

Distance the film maintains from realistic depictions of the holocaust enables the director to use history to remind the audience of the moral lessons that it contains. Life is Beautiful begins by stating that it is a fable, defying genre yet still it still sets out in its goal in influencing or creating new values and attitudes. A fable is a story often beyond reality, to provide a moral lesson. Fairy-tale cannon bookends the movie, it begins with a voiceover, “ This is a simple story, but not an easy one to tell. Like a fable, there is sorrow and, like a fable, it is full of wonder and happiness. ” The film is closed with, “This is the sacrifice my father made. This was his gift to me.” After spending months at Centro Documentazione Ebraica …show more content…

“ Benigni portrays elements of fantasy to show the Holocaust through the eyes of a small child, who is under the assumption the holocaust is a competitive game. “Benigni constructed phantom prison-believable, but with nondescript…and surrounded by fog…Benigni averts the opposite sin, of making us complicit in the child's dreamworld.” In his resplendent representation of the past Benigni insisted apparent inaccuracies were carefully created and deliberately employed. Shot through the classic cannons of a fairy-tale myths, symbols, metaphorical images were used to create an ,“indirect representation of a history assumed to be unrepresentable.” For example, the death camp is deliberately left nameless, allowing it to become a symbol of camps and evil in general. Challenges Benigni faces mirrors the difficulty of all holocaust art; the act of having to represent a reality controlled by people who are the anthesis of your own …show more content…

We say ‘tiredness’, 'fear', pain’. But they are free words created by men who lived in comfort and suffering in their homes…" Benigni taps into a new aspect of history and focuses on the social attitudes of the time and tries to impact the current state. Negative reviews claim the representation of the past could have a detrimental impact, “There is a serious point there - if we see films like that, at least subconsciously they end up giving the message that maybe it was not quite so bad after all.” In his representation Benigni was not trying to undermine the holocaust, from the beginning Benigni states that he is depicting a fable, not a historical documentary- he just wants to share moral lessons, as mentioned before he did not want to offend Jewish people through his depiction, he wanted to show their strength. “The charge of holocaust distortion… embodies the assumption the audience's understanding of the holocaust would be modified through their identification with the child's point of view- seems to underestimate the sophistication of the film and its audience.” In representing the past through a child’s perspective Benigni aims to influence or create values and attitudes essential to the moral consciousness post holocaust rather than accurately depict

Get Access