preview

Borderland

Satisfactory Essays

SOC 248T: Post-Soviet Paradoxes Ryan Kelley Professor Shevchenko November 16, 2016 Response to “The Bulgarian Borderland” by L. Melishkevich SUMMARY Main Claim of Paper: Religious divisions in Madan (and other Bulgarian towns in the Rhodope region) are produced by a religious borderland in which individuals grapple with ideological conflict and tension, characterized by Eastern vs. Western influences. Support: Factual information and quotes from Muslim Lives in Eastern Europe; Supportive information (for comparisons) from other books/places examined this semester. CONSTRUCTIVE FEEDBACK (with some complimentary questions) Argument: Pushing back against Ghodsee’s notion that Madan is unique due to the combination of its large Muslim populations and the collapse of GORUBSO, the paper builds off past discussions of borderland (with Where the World Ended and Consecution and Social Change) to argue that a religious borderland is responsible for divisions in the Bulgarian Muslim population. I have little critique of the broad argument (I think it’s rather brilliant!) BUT I think it suffers from organizational and evidence deficiencies. …show more content…

Is this borderland signifiant for the rest of Bulgaria? How? I admire how you took your paper road the road that Ghodsee appears hesitant to travel: You focus on the religious experience itself as significant rather than drawing connections to economic and political life. Why do you think Ghodsee expands her argument to include gender and ethnicity? How could your argument benefit from these other lines of

Get Access