preview

Cabaret Movie Comparison

Decent Essays

After watching both of the films for this week I definitely noticed a difference in the film narratives due to musical numbers and how they were integrated. While watching 42nd Street, the musical numbers were quite confusing to me. I struggled to understand how they provided context to the film. As I did not see how they fit within the storyline of the films. I also believe the disconnection between the numbers and the film made me question, the films event’s and I thought I misunderstood certain moments in the film because the musical numbers did not make sense. I also did not enjoy the fact that during the numbers themselves there was dialogue going on and the focus shifted during the number. I think this lessened the impact of the number …show more content…

It was as if the focus was the music numbers opposed to the films, which in my opinion is the best part of a musical. I enjoyed watching the numbers and seeing the elaborate costumes and details that were put into them. Furthermore, in Cabaret, one could tell that the music numbers really fit in with the film and provided more insight into what was going on. A good example of this was the during the musical number Maybe This Time sung by Sally which demonstrated her relationship with Brian and how it has evolved. Their relationship turned into more than a friendship and as the number goes on Sally sings of the hope she has of this relationship being the real deal and withstanding the test of time.Through this musical number the audience is able to understood how Sally is feeling without the use of any actual dialogue. I do believe there is some relation between the context of integration/non-integration and the contexts in which the films were made. 42nd Street was created during the Great Depression and it seems as if there was some caution in terms of the film was made. It seems as if the events of the film were more so on the safe side and no feathers were

Get Access