preview

Case Study Of Gathya Trademark Law

Decent Essays

Gathya Trademark Tiff
Gathya eatery brand trademark tiff is just another in the endless list of trademark battles. The instant case involves a farson shop namely Gathya, which has 7 branches and six franchisees in the city of Ahmedabad. The problem arose when a former employee started his own eatery business on a handcart with the same brand name- Gathya- appended by the words‘Laxmi Rath’. The court held that Gathya’s trademark’s scope of protection encompasses the defendant’s mark and it was quick to grant an interlocutory injunction against this free-riding use of the unregistered trademark. Though this is a prima facie case of passing off and trademark dilution, it raises interesting questions about the scope and the basis of Trademark Law.
Trademark Law is based on a consumer construct of the ‘ideal type’ despite severe criticism. To avoid the vagaries of a quotidian consumer, it bases itself on the standard of a ‘sovereign consumer’ who always seeks maximum utility and is capable of rational choice-making. This abstract consumer seeks information about the source of goods to predict their quality and he perceives a Trademark as a badge of origin. So, Trademark Law is based on this standard to ensure uniformity and stability, and to avoid confusion. …show more content…

Trademark dilution and infringement are subjective concepts based on concreteconsumer confusion. Hence, negative capability- the ability to perceive the market from the consumer’s viewpoint- is necessitated. But trademark law stubbornly sticks to the standard of the reasonable man. This also signifies the loss of the essence of trademark law: the protection of the brand image of trademarks in the consumer’s mind- that is, the concrete consumer’s conception and not that of the fictive

Get Access