preview

Charles Kenny 's Getting Better And Nina Munk 's Profile

Good Essays

PS 330 Comparative Review
Introduction
Charles Kenny’s Getting Better and Nina Munk’s profile of Jeffrey Sachs in The Idealist represents two distinct perspectives on how best to promote development and the challenges associated with implementing such transformative visions. Jeffery Sachs takes a very straight forward approach to problem of how to eradicate poverty. He claimed that in order to eradicate poverty all we need to do is increase the monetary aid these underdeveloped countries. While Charles Kenny takes a more holistic approach. He claims we should focus less income to determine development and focus more on human development factors in order to gradually promote development. After reading both of these books, I believe …show more content…

Initially a five-year project with the goal of proving “Sachs’s systematic, scientific approach to ending poverty could be used on a grand scale – in which case, millions upon millions of rural Africans would be rescued from the poverty trap and lifted to ‘the first rung on the ladder of development’” (38). His assumption was that if it can achieve positive results in one village it would possible replicate in other places as well. Yet, what he failed to understand was that poverty is not systematic. It is not organized and the problems that causes poverty is not the same everywhere.
Another problem with his model was that it only looked at the problems that were on the surface, for example in the millennium villages handbook “entire chapter had been devoted to improving agriculture yields, boosting school enrollment, and promoting gender equality. But nothing in the handbook told the agents how to reduce crime” (49). While model did have solution to basic problems that were behind the cause of poverty, it did not take into deeper problems that could be preventing the eradication of poverty. There were also cultural and religious beliefs and social conventions that interrupted the project. When Ahmed, one of the agents of the Millennium Villages Project tried to encourage the people of Dertu to cut grass in order to turn it into hay, he was met with opposition “‘god had brought us this grass,’ one man objected. ‘it is not ours to cut’” (53). These people were hard to

Get Access