Cold War Readings - Devil’s Advocate Response For my response, I have chosen to focus in on some of the statements provided by the Nussbaum reading as well as JFK’s “City Upon a Hill” speech. As the group’s Devil’s Advocate, I will strive to make logical and realistic counterpoints to some of the information from the readings that I found either unseemly, disingenuous, or unrealistic as it relates to our modern world.
The Nussbaum (it literally means “Nut Tree” in German) reading focused primarily on the idea that higher education should emphasize the ethical role and moral obligations of a “global citizen,” one that travels among other cultures and recognizes, or even adapts to, the cultural tenets of the so-called other. Two points of focus
…show more content…
Kennedy recanted to his audience during his famous “City Upon a Hill” speech the message that Pericles gave to the Athenian people: “We do not imitate - for we are a model to others.” In a similar fashion to the Nussbaum article, Kennedy addressed the distinctions between a local identity and a national identity, especially in relation to the obligations that one must hold to one or the other. In his case, Kennedy was making the appeal that despite his rise to power on a national level as President of the United States, he would still maintain his traditional views fostered by his Massachussetts upbringing. “It was here my grandparents were born,” he said, “it is here I hope my grandchildren will be born.” Therefore, even though Kennedy is recognizing his moral obligation to the country on a national level as its President, he is maintaining discourse with his local identity. An objection that I took with this message was that even though I found myself agreeing with a fair portion of its content, I’m not entirely bought on the idea that one should necessarily feel bound by obligation to their nation, especially when one can’t help the circumstances of their birth. What if my nation is inherently flawed, or even lawfully evil - like Nazi Germany - am I still bound by obligation to my nation? Because I happen to live here, am I robbed of my own agency to choose whether or not I support my government? Secondly, Kennedy addresses his audience with Pericles’ famous statement to the people of Athens, that “We do not imitate.” Ignoring the inherent flaws of American exceptionalism, I think it is a fundamental injustice to declare that one must only submit to original ideas of governance, rather than looking outward to other models for inspiration. Our founding fathers used primarily recycled ideas from the Enlightenment in order to craft the documents that would create America as we know it today, and so I do not think
Ethan David Cold War Responsibility During WWII, the Soviets crushed the Nazi’s leaving only the United States and Soviet Union as world powers. The US had also dropped weapons of mass destructions on Japan, leading to the withdrawal of Japan from WWII. Europe was also destroyed as a result of WWII, leading to the United States attempting a recovery plan, the Marshall Plan. The Soviet Union and its allies were more responsible than the United States for starting the Cold War because the Soviets threateningly attempted to convert many democratic countries into communist nations by the influence of such a large country (Russia), and the continued threat of attack by increasing weapon number and potential, also with mobilizing and building up
Clara Adil Homer History April 26, 2024 Soviets in Eastern Europe The Cold War was a disagreement between the United States and its allies, and the Soviet Union and its allies. It started in 1946 and lasted until 1991. The Cold War was a time of tension caused by each side wanting to spread their political ideology and power. The United States wanted to spread the democratic ideology whereas the Soviet Union wanted to spread a communist ideology throughout Eastern Europe.
The Cold War began with Winston Churchill, Prime Minister of Britain, giving a speech of imposing an, “iron curtain,” separating East and West Germany. The Soviet Union having control over East Germany, and the United States controlling West Germany. Berlin, the capital of Germany, was also separated, the Soviet Union took over East Berlin and Germany took over West Berlin. The countries had different government systems, the U.S. was Democratic and the Soviet Union was Communist. Tension started to build around the two world powers. Soon enough, a cold war broke out, the countries fought economically, politically and competed in an arms race against one another.
Following the events of World War 2, a new conflict arose. Except this one didn’t involve actual fighting. The Cold War began after reciprocated feelings of distrust and conflicting ideas about which government was best between the U.S. and U.S.S.R. While the Cold War affected life in the United States and the Soviet Union, it also influenced life in countries all over the world.
After World War II there was still a main conflict between the two major world superpowers; the US and allied countries that supported democracy and on the other hand the Soviet Union (USSR) who supported communism and wanted to spread it. The conflict was that the Soviet Union tried spreading communism in other countries, but the United States was not going to allow that. This conflict influenced the Cold War to be fought by the Eastern Bloc (Soviet Union) and Western Bloc (the United States and allies). When the Eastern Europe was taken over by the USSR and turned into communism the US helped the Western Europe to not be taken over by communism. As an adviser to the President of the United States the policy that he should follow is to rapidly build up the political,
As the biggest most tragic war known as WWII came to an end, many nations were relieved and happy. However, the happiness of these nations did not last long because a new conflict started emerging the cold war. It was tension between the United States and the Soviet Union. They both had different perspectives on the type of government. The United States believed in a democratic government while the Soviet Union believed in a communist government. This affected many nations around the world. Two nations that had a huge impact on the cold war were Europe and Asia.
The soviets are to blame for the start of the cold war. The cold war revolved around three conflicts, spheres of influence, ideology, and military factors. The soviets used these three conflicts to start the cold war. One way the soviets started the cold war was through spheres of influence. In document number two it says, “The following circumstances should not be forgotten.”
Document-Based Question Early Cold War Conservative historians state that the United States of America used American containment to avert further expansion of communist power from the U.S.S.R, and in doing so, prevented a global communist revolution. The Cold War was a period of tension and hostility that developed between the U.S and Soviet Union post-World War II. The Cold War rooted from an ideological conflict between America’s capitalist government and the Soviet Union’s communist administration. Communism is a totalitarian system of governing in which a single authoritarian party controls both the political and economic aspects of society, leading to absolute and total control held by just a few people in the central government. America
After World War two the two allies soon split. The United States and the Soviet Union were immediately against each other. This was the beginning of the Cold War. The three main causes of the Cold War were spheres of influence, ideology, and military factors. With my information, I believe that the Soviet Union was the most responsible for the Cold War.
The U.S policy of containment was the U.S’s way of stopping the spread of communism. Containment played a crucial part in the Cold War and determined the outcome of many events. For example, the Korean war, the Cuban Missile Crisis and, the incident in Berlin are all keen examples of the U.S’s containment policy. These events dramatically impacted the results of the Cold War.
The hysteria of the Cold War caused for many precautions. Throughout the mid 1900s, the spread of communism was causing concern to the United States. President Dwight D. Eisenhower worked to solve these issues both politically and socially to prevent further fear from the American citizens.
Research this week was fruitful and my bibliography grew substantially. A large part of the reason for this growth was the mining of the bibliography of other sources. One of the most fruitful was, The Cold War in a Cold Land: Fighting Communism on the Northern Plains. The book provided me with a variety of both primary and secondary sources. The list of sources includes, books, articles, and government reports. A second book that provided more sources was, How We Forgot the Cold War. The bibliography provided some sources created by the North Dakota State Historical Society. In addition to these sources, I have been looking into newspapers. I have ordered some rolls of microfilm of the Griggs County Sentinel-Courier and am still waiting for them to arrive. I started with these rolls because they came from the paper closest to the geographic center of my research, as well as the dates of my research. In addition to the rolls, I have ordered The Cold War in a Cold Land, which provided a list of other newspapers that may be useful. In addition to ordering more microfilm reels that I will have sent to me at school, I will also have the opportunity to examine many more when I return home for spring break. Many are housed at the State Historical Society, just twenty minutes
How did conflicting ideas in the Cold War turn the United States into a super power and could the strategies that helped fight them help the US fight terrorism? The Cold War was lasted from 1947 to 1991, which is 45 years in combat agents the Soviet Union. Even though there was no direct combat between the two countries, they both lost millions of dollars and lives. Both sides had their own ideas of how governments should be run; the United States had the idea of a capitalist while Russia had the idea of a communist (“The Cold”). During this time, Russia was spreading its beliefs across Europe by taking over Germany, Poland, Hungary, Romania, Bulgaria, Czechoslovakia (Czech Republic), Austria, and many others (“What”).
In 1961 President John F Kennedy put together a doctrine, which altered from President Eisenhower’s one. It was to “Respond flexibly to communist expansion, especially guerrilla warfare.” (Roskin & Berry, 2010, p. 58) It was a time when the Cold War was at its height and nuclear weapons a mass threat and source of power. This doctrine was aimed at using alternative means before opening into combat. This, in light of the Cuban Missile Crisis in 1962, it succeeded in doing.
When the second world war ended in 1945, the U.S. emerged as a world power. Even though America was already a major player, the dropping of the atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, as well as the defeat of Germany, made sure that America stayed on top. However, when the Cold War started in 1947, the race between the Soviet Union and the U.S. for top nation was on.