preview

Colleen Morgan Atwood Essay

Decent Essays

During the Cameron Hooker trial, there was a “battle of the experts” in which both the defense and prosecution called upon forensic psychologists as expert witnesses. Expert witnesses are used in cases to provide insight based on there area of expertise. The extensive knowledge they have in there field can hopefully clear up any misconceptions in the case for all those involved. One area in which the expert witnesses tried to clear discrepancies in the case was Colleen Stan’s submissiveness to Hooker as well as her lack of attempt to escape captivity. Dr. Chris Hatcher was present on behalf of the prosecution. His extensive work on terrorism, hostage negotiations, and brainwashing was used to describe Colleen Stan’s kidnapping as an extreme form of intimidation. He explained that the forms of control displayed towards Stan were enough to manipulate her into a behavioral pattern that satisfied Hooker. It was also argued that Stan's brainwashing changed the way information was processed as well as how she viewed the world. Dr. Donald Lunde was present on behalf of the defense. According to Lunde, Hooker threatened Stan’s family and did not directly threaten Stan. As a result, she was in fact not coerced …show more content…

The expert's testimonies and insight were beneficial to the outcome of the trial. Dr. Hatcher’s explanation of intimidation gave a clear picture as to how Hooker's tactics made Stan submissive to all of his demands. It also showed how she became depended on Hooker and how his actions toward her changed her mental state. Dr. Lunde’s testimony, however, was unreliable to the efforts the defense tried to make to clear Hooker. Although the expert witnesses played a significant role in the determination of the case, they were not the only means of evidence in this case. There was also a substantial amount of physical evidence that ultimately led to Hookers

Get Access