preview

Comparing "From the House of Yemanja" and "The Bistro Styx"

Decent Essays

Lyndsay Woolridge
Mr. J. Godbout
ENG3UY
March 7, 2010.
Falling Short of Perfection “From the House of Yemanjà” by Audre Lorde and “The Bistro Styx” by Rita Dove share the common theme of daughters falling short of their mother’s expectations. Though the poems have obvious differences, both successfully convey the theme from two opposing perspectives. Each perspective expresses the theme using a first person point of view, though in “The Bistro Styx,” the poem is narrated by a mother. It communicates a strong maternal concern and a sense of exasperated disappointment, while “From the House of Yemanjà” is written from a daughter’s perspective and lacks the same tenderness. If children feel inadequate in their parents’ eyes, I believe …show more content…

“The Bistro Styx” is an excerpt from Rita Dove’s “Motherly Love,” a book-length modernization of the Greek myth of Persephone. To summarize the myth, Persephone is abducted to the underworld by Hades, who had fallen deeply in love with her. Persephone’s mother, Demeter, became distraught, giving up eating and drinking in order to continuously search for her daughter. When she learned that Hades had brought her to the underworld, she bargains with him to free her. Although Persephone has learned to love Hades, he agrees to free her on the condition that she suffers as much as her mother has. Unfortunately, Persephone had eaten a few pomegranate seeds, as she was unaware that those who consumed the food of the underworld would never be able to be fully restored to the living world. Hades declares that Persephone may spend half of the year in the world of the living, and half as his queen in the land of the dead. Dove's contemporary version of the story tells of the character modeled after Persephone resurfacing in modern day Paris. The restaurant in which she and her mother meet is named after the Styx, which is “the river in the underworld over which dead souls [are] ferried.” There are varies similarities between the Greek myth and Dove’s poem. The poem’s characters parallel Persephone and her mother Demeter, and Hades is portrayed by a brooding artist who whisks the daughter to Paris, causing the

Get Access