preview

Comparing Rebekah's Essay 'Individual And Community'

Good Essays

Geoff Ward
ENG 101 Composition
C. Hammond
14 Oct 14
Collective independence.
“Individual” and “community” are two words whose meanings contrast each other. An individual is one who is not reliant on others and exists as its own entity. A community however, is a group of individuals, whose efforts are combined and improved with help from others, therefore becoming reliant on each other. Both Rebekah Nathan and Kwame Anthony Appiah speak a great deal on what makes or breaks a community, what brings individuals together and what separates them. I argue that communities are successful when individuals are made to feel like their identity is maintained, and their voice carries weight.

In her essay, “Community and Diversity”, Rebekah Nathan unveils …show more content…

Its only through communication between these communities, ultimately the communication of individuals is consensus reached on those standards. He dubs the efforts of this communication as “cosmopolitanism”. People tend to only think of themselves as having the correct views on the world and are less accepting of the beliefs of others, its human nature. I agree with Appiah as he says how small agreements essential to eventually having two cultures that work in harmony for long periods of time …show more content…

These are communities that are working for the members participating, not just the utilitarian ride share and study groups that Nathan had remarked on. The members participating had an active role in their local community, they were fulfilling an obligation to the other members the talent show. While not as grandiose as Appiah’s explanation “…We have obligations to others, obligations that stretch beyond those to whom we are related by the ties of kith and kind or even the more formal ties of a shared citizenship” (69, Appiah), the participants were still fulfilling a needed

Get Access