preview

Comparing Relationships In Oranges And Black Swan Green

Good Essays

The poem titled “Oranges” by Gary Soto is a story about a boy who is poverty stricken but sees positivity in his life as well. The tone changes at times from positive to gloomy and wary. “Black Swan Green” is written by David Mitchell through the eyes of thirteen year old Jason Taylor living in a small village in England. The novel’s thirteen chapters depict thirteen months of his life filled with much struggle and many experiences. Although the two texts contrast in regards to values due to time periods and relations due to money, they are similar as the characters experiences influence their relationships. As Soto’s poem “Oranges,” is written in the 1980’s, this time period reflects the attitude towards relationships. The main male character …show more content…

In the novel Jason’s parents argue over money even though they are doing well as a middle class. However in the poem the boy doesn’t have money but that helps him and the girl be together “A nickel in my pocket/And when she lifted a chocolate/that cost a dime… When I looked up/ the lady’s eyes met mine/ And held them, knowing/Very well that it was all/About” (Soto 31-42). This quote shows that the boy and girls relationship works out even though the boy didn’t have much money. Within the poem the relationship is not negatively affected by the boy’s lack of money. Firstly the cashier agrees to accept the little money he has rather than cause a fight. Secondly, his girlfriend inclined to stay with him even though she is aware that he does not have a lot of wealth “I took my girls hand/ In mine for two blocks” In the novel, Jason’s parents fight due to money “Dad watches all this through the kitchen window. Dad isn’t laughing. He’s won” (Mitchell 115), was the result of an argument about money between his parents. Money makes his parent drift apart and causes a negative barrier between his family. Therefore money can affect relationships but there is no correlation between amount of money and the success of a …show more content…

As Jason spends time with his father his views towards his father change “Dad never gives me things like this for no reason, not just out of the blue.” (Mitchell 219) He accompanies his father on a business trip but sees his father’s shortcomings and fear. Additionally, Jason goes to see a movie with his mother and he sees how she copes with the situation in her marriage by becoming successful In the poem the boy experiences not having enough money to pay for the chocolate to impress his girl but luckily the cashier understood him and is able to help him changing his relationship with the girl. Additionally, in the poem, the boy is able to get the chocolate for the girl when the cashier lets him which begins a relationship with the girl. “Black Swan Green is a semi biographical novel, containing many details from Mitchells experience as an adolescent most notable his struggle with a debilitating stammer, personified in the book as “hangman” As a result of Jason’s debilitating stammer he comes across many new life situations being bullied. “We seen yer! In Cheltenham! Queueing with yer mummy” (Mitchell 197). Although he is bullied he gains more confidence in dealing with bullies and also has more insight on the things happening around him. Therefore, due to the varying life experiences of the character in the two texts their relationships have

Get Access