preview

Comparing Teacher Read-Alouds And Round-Robin Reading

Decent Essays

Two strategies I witnessed firsthand in my field placement, but were deemed ineffective were Teacher Read-Alouds and Round-Robin Reading. Choosing these to as unsuccessful is polarizing, because Teacher Read-Alouds are usually characterized as effective, whereas Round-Robin Reading is considered an outdated method. In fact, McLaughlin states that one of all educators’ main goals should be to eliminate this “dated method of reading” from all classrooms (141). While these strategies were both deemed ineffective, they were used in very different scenarios and the Read-Aloud was not the teacher’s choice. The Teacher Read-Aloud strategy was witnessed during an Indiana Statewide Testing for Educational Progress (ISTEP) practice test. It was mentioned …show more content…

The book that was being read was Don Quixote. This strategy is not recommended because it puts students on the spot and often requires them to read when they are not comfortable with it. This strategy is a quick was for educators to have students read the material with putting little effort into the composition of the learning environment. McLaughlin states that this strategy usually does not allow students the chance to activate background knowledge prior to reading. McCown however, helped scaffold the process by showing students a video regarding the subject matter before the reading began. Was this enough to balance the negative impact of this strategy? Probably not. This is because another issue with Round-Robin Reading is that most students will take their turn and read, and then ignore the rest of the reading while their peers take their turns (McLaughlin, 2015, p. …show more content…

In M464, it was said that a purpose must be set for reading and questioning is a vital aspect of the transactional reading process (M464 session 2 module). Both of these seemed to fit more into a transmission model of teaching. The Teacher Read-Aloud was simply in place to get the students to hear the information. It is unlikely that the reader of the ISTEP instructions actually believes that students are engaged and actively listening to every word they say. When the Round-Robin Reading was used, there was very little time in class. Therefore, it seemed more like a quick way to introduce the students to the text. Perhaps the class would go back over the material that was read during this session, which is unknown without further observation sessions. In short, both of these strategies were used to quickly give students information. Assessment methods of these strategies included students successfully following the directions the teacher was reading, and students successfully reading the excerpts during the Round-Robin

Get Access