preview

Comparing the Role of Women in Indian Camp and Shiloh Essay

Better Essays

Role of Women in Indian Camp and Shiloh

The women of "Indian Camp" experience a life much different from the woman in "Shiloh." Ernest Hemingway wrote "Indian Camp" giving the women a definite role in their families while Bobbi Ann Mason wrote "Shiloh" leaving the woman’s definite family role ambiguous. Because they are responsible for the birth of the babies, the Native American women of the preceding story are the nurturers as opposed to the men. The women accept their roles and partake in their duties without any protest. On the other hand, Norma Jean’s role is not as traditional compared to the other women’s since she and Leroy have no children, she basically lives alone, and she maintains a job. While the Native American …show more content…

The doctor responds by saying, "No. I haven’t any anesthetic. But her screams are not important" (16). Everyone in the room knows she feels intense pain, but only the little boy requests relief of her pain. The women must be used to births without pain relief because of the way they live or else one of them would have questioned the doctor’s operation. The birth is clearly a woman’s responsibility and a woman’s own experience in the camp because if it were not, the men would be helping or at least ready to give their congratulations. Like the Native American women, Norma Jean seems complacent with her duties of cooking and cleaning for Leroy. However, she cannot hide her true feelings for long. Until now, Leroy has been on the road and away from their home for fifteen years, and she feels awkward having him around. While he has devoted his life to truck driving and nothing else, Norma Jean seeks a better life for herself. For example, she completed a body building course, continues to lift weights, and is taking a composition course. Although the courses contribute nothing to her current job at the drug store, she feels good about herself for completing them. Leroy, on the other hand, is at a standstill in his life. He feels no urge or to do anything useful: "He is not sure what to do next. In the

Get Access