preview

Critical Analysis Of Disgrace

Good Essays

Disgrace, a novel by J.M. Coetzee, portrays how disgrace is always there, yet evolves over time. The disgraces portrayed in the book range from personal shame, as is the case with Lucy and Melanie, to public regret, as shown through the board members, robbers, Petrus, and animals. Despite the many disgraces mentioned in the novel, Coetzee’s overall underlying focus for the story is to show how David comes to terms with his disgrace. From the first page it is clear David is our protagonist as the story begins with him. Then, we follow through his problems and his internal struggle and finally we end with his resolution. One of the other critical characters, Melanie, has an ambiguous and unresolved ending, her plot is set in such a way …show more content…

Right as he says this, his guilt kicks in. His disgrace is starting to build as he corrects himself by adding: “But if she has got away with much, he has got away with more; if she is behaving badly, he has behaved worse” (28). This is the first major moment in the story where Melanie’s actions because of her disgrace are left to the reader’s interpretations and are instead used to further David as he tries to understand his disgrace.
From here, we find out through a conversation between Melanie’s father and David that she is dropping out of college. This is another action that Melanie takes because of the disgrace she feels, but the reader is never made clear of what she was actually going through when making that decision. In fact, when her father makes both the reader and David know what Melanie is about to do, Coetzee uses this time to stress how this affects David’s disgrace without sparing a moment to focus on Melanie’s shame. Here we see David’s disgrace has slowly grown as he replies to Mr. Isaacs’s claim that Melanie respects him. To this he thinks “respect? You are out of date, Mr Isaacs. Your daughter lost respect for me weeks ago, and with good reason” (37). A few lines later it is again evident that his disgrace has grown by Melanie’s actions as he states “How can I help you when I am the source of your woes?” (37). While dropping out

Get Access