preview

D. A. Muise: Article Analysis

Decent Essays

The Fourth week readings by Peter De Lottinville and D. A. Muise present an insight of the economic and social struggles occurring in the Maritimes in the 19th and 20th century. De Lottinville describes the economic downfalls and risings of the St. Croix mill , whereas Muise describes the challenging times for the wages women obtained in Nova Scotia . Both articles represent the lifestyles of Canadians in the Maritimes and the social and financial issues faced by families in the 19th and 20th century. The main argument in the articles from week 4 discusses how industrialization affected the lives of families, but more importantly the women of the Maritimes. The two articles provide insight into the theme of industrialization and family …show more content…

In the Maritimes around 1870s-1900s, survival was a top priority. These two articles explained why their articles contain the economic need for the Maritimes to prosper at this time period. Thirdly, the articles elaborate on the idea of women being paid. This was a crucial factor when it came to the developments of industrialism and family life. In De Lottinville’s article, he mentions the low paid wages women received during the industrial wave. Muise examines women’s participation in the paid workforce, which remained limited, especially in the coal industry. Overall, these similarities help demonstrate the conditions of industrialization and family life in the Maritimes in the 19th and 20th century. The individual difference between the two articles is the concept of women being involved in the industrial process. In De Lottinville’s article, he examines how women filled two thirds of the positions that did not have many opportunities in the lumber industry. Compared to Muse’s article, where women received few jobs compared to men and were paid less, De Lottinville argues that women received jobs because of the growing industrial …show more content…

In the beginning, he captures the reader’s attention by stating different scenarios of women in Nova Scotia. He then proceeds to layout his pages by the status and wages of women. He discusses the status of women compared to men, and then the status of single and married women. His structure was effortless and captivating for the reader because it was uncomplicated. The article is a simple read, which means the information was more comprehensible. Conversely, De Lottinville’s premises were not as strong as Muise’s when represented because there was too much information to understand; the material was not engaging at all. The article would contain interesting facts; however, it was shadowed by unnecessary information. While Muse was very good at organizing his thoughts, De Lottinville was not. Muise also includes censuses in his articles, which help illustrate the numbers of women in certain fields, or the wages they received. This builds a strong picture for the reader to see how the developments of women changed. By adding censuses, the reader will have a better understanding of the information. De Lottinville’s content was fairly convenient. All questions were answered when it came to the rise of the industry, but the read was not stimulating or thrilling in

Get Access