preview

Darwinism in Great Expectations by Charles Dickens Essay examples

Better Essays

Few people argue that Great Expectations, one of Dickens’s later novels, is a Darwinian work. Goldie Morgentaler, in her essay “Meditating on the Low: A Darwinian Reading of Great Expectations,” is one of those few. She argues primarily that Darwin’s Origin of the Species was a major topic of discussion in Dickens’s circle at the time he wrote Great Expectations, and that Great Expectations “marks the first time that Dickens jettisons heredity as a determining factor in the formation of the self” (Morgentaler, 708). This fascinating insight draws one to read more of Morgentaler’s essay. It does not, however, compel the reader to admit that Dickens became Darwinian. Morgentaler’s main argument, though useful, could point just as …show more content…

Although she says that, “hereditary transmission is the sine qua non of evolutionary theory” and, in other writers of the late nineteenth century, this “intensif[ied] interest in heredity as a literary theme” (709), she concludes that Darwin’s influence on Dickens was to let him “shake off his earlier adherence to heredity as a way of explaining personality” (709). In other words, Darwin’s impact on Dickens was to make Dickens reject Darwin’s major point. This implies that Dickens was, in reality, an anti-Darwinian, someone who saw that Darwinian thought was dangerous, and who therefore, in reaction, tried to remove elements from his own worldview that led to the same evolutionary conclusions as Darwin proposed. He was as Darwinian as someone who reads Kant and rejects the idea of mental categories is Kantian.

To show how this is true, it is necessary to demonstrate how Dickens’s rejection of hereditary influence in Great Expectations creates a novel that is actually quite opposed to evolutionary theories. Morgentaler’s own observations provide the material for this demonstration. While earlier books by Dickens had insisted “on the essential godliness of the goodhearted . . . amenable to hereditary transmission from one generation to the next,” here, “the emphasis on the ideal has given way to a demonstration of the omnipresence of the base” (715). This theme of guilt, lowness, and criminality is truly one of the central traits

Get Access