preview

Determining The Soluble Ion In Part III

Decent Essays

The spot test in table 1.1 were vitally important to determining the soluble ion in step III. Only the major reactions that produced a strong change in color were recorded as a precipitate reaction. Other minor reactions that had a very minimal change in texture or color weren’t recorded as a precipitate. For example during the spot test in part I HCl and Fe(NO) produced a very diluted tinge of yellow. But when researching the actual reaction there most likely shouldn’t have been a precipitate. In table 2.1 the given reagents and metal ion reactions are given as they reacted with each other. This was done hugely with the help of the solubility rules given in the lab manual. Once recognizing which ions had a positive and negative charge from …show more content…

Part III began with adding HCl to the unknown mixture. By using table 1.1 it is clear that the only ions that reacted with HCl were Lead and Silver. A precipitate formed so it became clear that either Silver or Lead was contained in the unknown solution. After being heated and centrifuged the remaining solid indicated a presence of Silver. The spot test tested negative for Lead. This could be done by using any of the reagents except DMG (referring to results from table 1.1). Any of the others would have produced an abrupt color change with the presence of Lead in the unknown solution but it was not. With the addition of NH4OH, this should have ruled out Iron in the unknown mixture although in table 1.1 there was a small reaction between the two. Theoretically, the combination of NH4OH and Iron should have formed a precipitate but this isn’t what happened in the experiment. When DMG was added a solid formed, confirming the reaction on table 1.1 which indicated that Nickel was in the unknown solution. The spot test came back positive for Barium which contradicts table 1.1 as a non-reaction. Regardless of what table 1.1 predicted, it was confirmed that the unknown solution contained Silver, Nickel, and …show more content…

This was successful by determining that the unknown solution contained Silver, Nickel, and Barium. However, the results in Part III didn’t match completely with those of Part I. According to table 1.1 NH4OH should have reacted with Fe(NO3) resulting in either Fe(OH)3 or Fe3+ being present in the unknown solution. Also Barium wasn’t predicted to precipitate with DMG. Possible sources of error could include: The miscommunication between partners as to which reagents were being added to which metal ions, the spot plate leaving residue to show a false reaction or the absence of a reaction. To avoid this is later experiments it would prove successful to label all chemicals, wash and dry all equipment when necessary to avoid

Get Access