Does College Matter in HRM? Dennis Keritsis
Imagine a man dressed up in a three thousand dollar business suit by Zegna, a pair of black polished men’s oxford dress shoes, and cleanly shaven. He is walking into an bleak empty interview room. Oddly, instead of seeing a panel of interviewers, he is given a laptop and told to write a computer program. This person was me. Taking the day off work, I drove up to Atlanta for a job interview for a software engineering position. Nearing my graduation in the Mercer MBA program, I am trying to take my career to the next level and find a better job. As I advanced in my career, I am starting to question how much of a competitive edge does as degree give. The whole interview was the programming project.
…show more content…
It is important to understand how individual make decisions psychologically. For very “involving” tasks and “complex” tasks, much time is needed to make a prudent decision. However, under situational influences, individuals have to make a decisions quickly without researching the topic in depth. When this happens, people use something called heuristics to make decisions. For example, people use “appeal to authority.” This is when individuals trust others like police officers, doctors, and other dividuals who have been through some form of qualification process that “signals” to them they can trust their judgement. Instead of the making very “complex” and “involving” decisions themselves, they trust experts who should know more about the topic than they do. The same process is true when hiring a new employee. Situational influences, like a tight budget, in the work environment do not always allow for the most in depth interview process. Thus, employers use heuristics to simplify the process in the decision making process. The heuristic discussed is called signaling, and specifically when discussing a diploma is called the Sheepskin effect (degrees use to be printed on sheep skins). Employers have a lot of applications to go through and they need a quick and easy way to filter through all the clutter. Using the heuristic process, they put applicants through a GPA filter and where (if they went at all) they went to school. A …show more content…
The videos in Mr. University note that there is a pay differential for the different types of degrees out there with Engineering taking the top spots and Art history and other humanities at the bottom. If college didn’t provide students with valuable skills, why is there a pay differential? Looking at Art History yearly salaries and comparing these to individual who have no college education, there is only a slightly higher pay for Art History graduates. This might be the Sheepskin effects which are practically negligible. Engineering graduates earn up to 60,000 (I have heard at most 140,000 starting off) starting off. Engineers take a completely different set of courses from Humanities majors with a minimal amount of electives. This means that the skills that engineers are developing are needed for the job market. In the vein of Adam Smith’s economic theory, engineering taking a narrow set of math,science, and engineering courses is representative of the division of labor needed in a capitalistic market. If individuals are to command higher salaries, the skills are to be narrowed such that all individuals in a society are to perform work in module roles. The engineering curriculums being narrowed in this way does not seem to be coincidental. Lastly, it is worth noting that engineers make more than other professions and if other
Alex Tabarrok once said, “Education is the key to the future: You’ve heard it a million times, and it’s not wrong. Educated people have higher wages and lower unemployment rates, and better-educated countries grow faster and innovate more than other countries. But going to college is not enough. You also have to study the right subjects” (Reich par. 5). This quote is a very popular quote because it is a true to connection to education. The general assumption about college consists of how important it is to personal success, our future, and our general lives. However, questioning whether college is really important or not is becoming increasingly more popular in our society. Going to college is commonly one of the biggest decisions that we make in our lives so let me ask you this question, is college necessary for personal success?
The engineering field has the highest paid major, whereas the education field has the lowest paid major. "According to Census's calculations, the lifetime earnings of an education or arts major working in the service sector are actually lower than the average lifetime earnings of a high school graduate" (Owen and Sawhill 216). That statistic should really be taken into consideration when determining whether or not college is "worth it" or not. Making less than a high school graduate, on top of the expenses from college would make college not "profitable". In contrast, a mechanical engineer is projected to make around thirty-five thousand more a year than one with only a high school diploma. Different majors can make different amounts of
When it comes to embarking on post secondary education the views of it’s importance and relevance is controversial. In Murray’s Op-Ed piece, “Should The Obama Generation Drop Out”, he believes a college education is unnecessary. I, however disagree with Murray’s notion. College is necessary according to a person’s career choice and it’s requirements.
Throughout the USA college tuition has increased drastically; in the last five years Georgia colleges have had 75% increase along with other states such as Arizona whose tuition has increased by 77% (NPR). Since 2006 the tuition in Utah has increased by 62.8% and is rising throughout the U.S. (Desert News). Between 1885-2016 the price of college has increased between 2.1% to 4.3% per year beyond inflation (CollegeBoard). Through calculations, that equates to about a hundred precent increase since 1885. It’s no secret that college tuition has skyrocketed, increasing student debt and leaving prospective students to ask “Is College Worth It?” college education is beneficial in that it teaches students valuable life lessons in responsibility, prepares students to enter the workforce and can be relatively inexpensive. The eduction is “college education” is worth every penny but America has created clichés to define the college experience which are expensive and unnecessary. In a radical new world a college education is required in many high paying jobs, which leads to the question “Is the experience of college all it is built up to be?” Through recent research, many articles and news mention about the value of higher education seem to only take account of is the financial aspect. A college education is worth what one makes it and is an investment in a future and in one’s self. The purpose of college the education is to be prepared to go into a the workforce having gained the
This website will give me statistics of the level of education that Americans have completed in various years. The statistics vary by age, median earnings, and poverty rates giving me various groups of people to look at and compare. The source is credible as they get their statistics from the United States Census.
College is a place for higher education. Many people go there for further study every year. Meanwhile, plenty of people skip college or drop out of college. Sort of people believe college is not worth because it cost too much. Most people think college is worth because you will able to get a good job when you holding a degree. Yes, because being a college graduate can help you gain more than the money you spent to pay for college.
Although someone without a degree may have more natural intelligence and ability than their credentialed counterpart, a degree is now worth more than actual capability in the job market. Bankston writes that “the popular emphasis placed on higher education in a society in which higher education has become a broad expectation has heightened the importance of credentials as an asset for obtaining a job at the expense of other assets, such as demonstrated ability or experience in a field” (p. 337). A degree provides a form of merit that employers look for immediately because the degree marks the individual as someone who can supposedly meet deadlines, fulfill obligations, and think critically. Margolis (2007) remarks how “it was the common practice of my colleagues to immediately sift out the [resumes] that didn’t have a degree and just throw them away” (p. 42). Because many employers are searching through high volumes of resumes, they don’t have time to thoroughly look at every single one; they speed up the process by simply filtering out
There are many young americans at the end of high school debating whether or not do they want to go to college and is it worth the cost. There are many reason to tell why college is worth it to those who think it is not.
Some wonder whether or not college is worth the time and money. Two essays, “Plan B. Skip College” by Jacques Steinberg, and “Is College Worth the Money?” by Stephen G. Emerson, both discuss this topic and bring different views and insights. Although Steinberg and Emerson both write on the same topic, they use different writing strategies and styles. Both essays have varying styles, arguments, use of metaphors, and utilization of other sources in their essays.
I am going to base my argument of whether college still matters in our community today on three American authors that is Andrew Delbanco, Alex Tobarrok, Michelle Singletary and Maria Dimera to come up with my view of whether I will agree to it or not. According to me, college is very important and everyone is supposed to have equal chances to join college and get a degree of his or her choice. I also advocate for all majors in the degree to have equal job opportunities as we all work hard id college to have a bright future and secure a good job in the job market. In addition to all these, I also recommend that the government should offer training to all high school leavers in order to train and advise them on how to choose college courses and what to major at to avoid people in the job market with degree courses that are not competitive at all. I also recommend that college offerdegrees in relation to what the market needs to avoid bringing a massive number of people to the job market more than the jobs available. The government should reduce this by availing courses that is competitive in the market at the needed time and I believe this will improve the economy greatly.
Do you remember playing dress-up when you were young and trying on all sorts of costumes such as doctor coats, dentist scrubs, or astronaut suits? Since we were little, we have been preparing ourselves for choosing a career. We start realizing that the careers we have been looking into require a college education. College to some students may seem unnecessary, but students who attend college receive knowledge and earn high achievements in life.
Society today is often very pressuring towards young adults when it comes to attending college. Maybe it’s because it is the most appropriate idea for people. College provides the average human with a higher satisfaction of life due to the experience and the positives outcomes than that of someone who chooses not to go to college. Although college results in the possibility of debt afterwards, it is still worth the journey.
The article “A College Degree Isn’t Enough” by Kiplinger Knight, December 1, 2013 is a persuasive article because the author believes a college degree isn’t enough to land a job. Others may think otherwise. The author has this point of view due to the fact increasing number of employers have grown skeptical of degrees and other traditional credentials. Companies didn’t care much about a college degree or any achievement for that matter. Therefore, began a trend toward employer testing, which is fueled by a backlash against the high cost of four-year colleges and mounting student debt. Universities have been just too much money. A similar attitude is driving the trend toward condensed, tailored education, such as vocational training or an associate's degree from a community college. The way the author argues is informative and clear but the position he takes is disagreeable.
Many students see college as the stepping stone to a successful career and a happy life. Which can be true for some, however, many overlook whether college will actually help them succeed, or if college will truly be right for them. College is expensive and it is not for every kid who graduates high school, although it is marketed that way, high school graduates must think critically about their decision. Should I take some time away from school, to know myself better? What do I intend to do for a career? Am I more interested in educating myself toward things that interests me now and discovering my major as I learn, or do I feel I know what I want to do? And also essential questions like, how much debt will I go into? And can I
Attending college for the first time is an important, rewarding decision that I made for a good reason. I learned a lot about myself that will help me in my future. Setting goals, having expectations, and reflecting why I am in college is incredible to think about.