preview

Does Eudora Welty's Why I Live At The P. O?

Decent Essays

Eudora Welty’s Why I Live at the P.O. is a short story narrated by Sister, a woman whose younger sister, Stella-Rondo, returns home with her child after separating from her husband. In the story, Sister is a narcissist and suffers from first-child syndrome. Therefore, her interpretation of the incidents described in the story are unreliable due to the story being told through the tainted lenses of the jealous and attention-seeking older sibling. M. Farouk Radwan, MSc., notes that first-born children who are used to getting all of the attention until the second child arrives may develop feelings of jealousy because they blame their younger sibling for their dethronement. If properly developed, the first born can acquire positive qualities like strong leadership traits and being responsible. However, poor development can lead older siblings to manifest jealousy or …show more content…

Radwan describes these traits as including competitiveness and selfishness, both which could have been driving Stella-Rondo’s antagonistic behavior toward Sister. For example, according to Sister, Stella-Rondo is upset that Uncle Rondo is wearing one of her pieces of lingerie out in the yard. Though Stella-Rondo tells Uncle Rondo that “Sister has been devoting this solid afternoon to sneering out my bedroom window at the way you look” (Kennedy & Gioia, 2016, p. 51). Several times throughout the story, Sister describes incidents of someone trying to turn another person against her. She accuses Papa-Daddy of turning Uncle Rondo against her, Stella-Rondo of turning Papa-Daddy against her, describes Stella-Rondo’s turning Uncle Rondo against her over the lingerie incident, acts as though Mama turned on her in favor of Stella-Rondo, and believes even the baby is on Stella-Rondo’s side. In other words, the whole world, or just her whole world, are out to get

Get Access