preview

Does God Have A Big Toe By Eilberg-Schwartz

Good Essays

Invisible Bodies
Throughout the history of Judaism, many different approaches have been taken in imagining God’s body. While some have simply avoided the question, others have made serious efforts to prevent, and destroy, images of God. Howard Eilberg-Schwartz, a former anthropologist, explores the ways and reasons why Jewish men have sought to conceal depictions of an embodied male God in his book God’s Phallus. What Eilberg-Schwartz does not answer is how the decision of Jewish men to hide the male divine body affects depictions of the Jewish female body. Mary Shields, author of the article Multiple Exposures, writes about how the effects of an absent male body allows for the hypervisibility and exposure of women’s bodies. She notes how, …show more content…

Eilberg-Schwartz presents the example of the children’s book Does God Have a Big Toe?, in which only does the preservation of masculinity affect the women’s bodies, but their roles in culture as well. In the book, a Jewish girl, Arinna, asks her mother if God has a big toe, like everyone in her family does. Arinna’s mother is too busy to tell her daughter what she is supposed to: “God is the creator of the universe. God has made each of us in God’s image. But God is not a person. And that is why God does not have a big toe” (Eilberg-Schwartz 79). So Arinna asks the men in her family, but they do not know. Arinna’s question goes unanswered, so eventually she asks if God has a bellybutton. As mentioned earlier, different body parts are discussed in order to avoid the question of God’s genitalia. If Arinna asks about the belly button, which is closer to genitalia than toe, she will soon ask a much riskier question unless her mother intervenes. Had Arinna’s mother answered her, Arinna would not have continued to ask questions, and would have accepted the ambiguity of God’s body. Somehow, in this story, Jewish women have the cultural responsibility of concealing the divine body, and, by extension, preserving Jewish ideas of masculinity, patriarchy, and

Get Access