preview

Essay about Dr. Heideggers Experiment: Reality Or Illusion

Decent Essays

Dr. Heidegger's Experiment: Reality or Illusion

In Nathaniel Hawthorne's short story Dr. Heidegger's Experiment, one of the central ideas of the story revolves around the idea of reality versus illusion. Of course the overriding theme of the story dealt with the ethical dilemma of changing old age into youth, still a major part of how the story was interpreted involved a personal decision on how you took the story; as literal or figurative. The perception that appealed to me the most was reading the text as literal, and concluding the experiment as reality rather then a figment of imagination caused by the intoxicating brew.

A couple of points that Hawthorne made led me to …show more content…

After the first drink of the potion until the last, I was still led to the opinion that what the guests were experiencing was in fact real and completely genuine. At this point I will point out that it is at this exact moment where the issue of reality versus illusion begins to take shape.
However, while we left to toil with this intriguing notion, it seems quite intentional on the part of Hawthorne to make us decide on which side we are for.
I would say his reasoning for dividing us would be to point out that while it may be real or a delusion it's ethical and moral message should be clear cut to everyone. Backtracking for a second though, I would also like to dispute the argument of illusion as some people fight in favor, of on the sole occurrence of the old images in the mirror. It seems to me that as I mentioned above, a ploy set by Hawthorne to add a little twist to the story, and give us the readers something to think about. While we could argue that what they are seeing is a direct influence of the potion it would be far stretched to say that what they felt and how they acted was fake too. Keeping in mind that these people are very old and probably way passed their days of jumping around dancing about, it is pretty hard to say that this water gave them enough energy and vigor to move around like youngsters but still be contained in their old
bodies.

Get Access