preview

Emotion And Abortion

Decent Essays

The literature agrees that emotions play a central role in most important life events. Bailey, quoting Professor Ray Dolan of University College, London, writes in an interview “that emotions influence our decisions all the time” (p. 29).14 It is also agreed that the psychological element of abortion cannot be ignored because abortion is, without doubt, an important life event causing high psychological stress at the time.15 Argent suggests that abortion may involve feelings of guilt, shame and regret.16 Yet others disagree, suggesting that the experience of abortion is emotionally benign despite acknowledgement in the same article that “abortion represents one of the most contentious political, social and moral issues of the day”.17 The literature …show more content…

Avalos considers that the passage of time is an important variable when women consider their abortion in later years. She further argues that static models have guided research in this field even though women’s lives continually grow and change.19 Despite the vast amount written, the literature does not do justice to the complexity and depth of individuals’ abortion experiences and current research on this important topic is inadequate and inconclusive.20,21 Additionally, the question of what type of emotions women experience is not answered despite documented research efforts over the past 30 years. Indeed, in a position statement by the Royal College of Psychiatrists on 14 March 2008, the College concludes that the specific issue of whether or not abortion has harmful effects on women’s mental health “remains to be fully …show more content…

These authors highlight the inappropriate generalisation of conclusions from these studies and suggest they are “of limited scientific merit and tell little about the experience of the vast majority of abortion patients” (p. 1197).23 There is much less documented information regarding the potential positive effects that abortion may bring to the women, or the effects on women when abortion is denied, an exception being the paper by Dagg (1991).24 The literature tends to suggest that women who do not experience distress following abortion may experience more positive emotions such as relief, satisfaction and a sense of return to normality.25 Post-abortion emotions vary greatly between women, and therefore it would be misrepresentative to present abortion as a process that is inevitably associated with suffering and

Get Access