preview

Ender Receivable Case

Decent Essays

Both Chris and Robin know the collectability of material receivable from Ender Corporation is in doubt and Chris thinks that allowance for Ender receivable should be adjusted. However, their construction company requires a bank loan due to its financial difficulties so Robin is reluctant to adjust the allowance as it might affect the loan they are applying for and if the construction company do not get a clean audit opinion, the bank might also not approve their loan causing them to close down. The appropriate accounting treatment in this case will be to increase the allowance for Ender receivable since there is a high possibility that Ender will not be able to provide the materials owed. The primary stakeholders are Chris, Robin, the auditor, …show more content…

Under utilitarianism, doing nothing benefits Robin as the company would have lower risk of going out of business and employees including Chris will get to keep their jobs if company remain in business. Under justice principle, it will also be better to do nothing because if Chris chooses to report and adjust the allowance honestly which causes the bank to reject the loan, it will unfair for the employees as they might lose their jobs for Chris to maintain his integrity. On the other hand, under rights theory, the auditor and bank have the rights to the truth and accurate information while Chris has the rights to maintain his integrity. Chris also has the responsibility to provide accurate information as the controller of the company. Therefore, Chris should adjust the allowance. The possible alternatives for Chris can be doing nothing, notifying the auditors about Ender’s receivable and making adjustments for the full amount, adjusting the allowance moderately instead of the total amount or revealing the collectability of materials receivable from Ender in the financial statements and not changing the numbers. In this case, the practical constraint is that keeping Ender’s doubtful receivable from the auditor and bank might be considered as a financial statement fraud causing Chris and Robin to face legal

Get Access