preview

Essay On Moore's Paradox

Good Essays

On Moore’s paradox and its solutions The meaning of assertion and belief is an important topic in philosophy of language. One of intriguing problems in this area is Moore’s paradox, which tries to explain why Moore’s statements cannot be sincerely asserted without absurdity. The purpose of this paper is to explain and explore the reason for absurdities in Moore’s paradox. Specially, I will first offer certain background knowledge on logical and performative contradiction, and then proceed to analyze several forms of Moore’s paradox. Also, I will present several solutions for Moore’s paradox and the analysis for its solutions. There are two categories of contradictions in the logic of philosophy : performative contradiction and logical contradiction. A logical contradiction is the conjunction of a statement p and its denial not-p. For example, if p is the statement that one plus one equals two.Then the conjunction between the statement that one plus one equals two and the statement that one plus one doesn’t equal two is a logical contradiction. A performative contradiction occurs when the content of a statement contradicts either the act of asserting it or the presuppositions of …show more content…

There are two forms of representation of Moore’s paradox.The omissive form of Moore’s paradox is that p & I do not believe that p. There are also two commisive forms of Moore’s paradox. The first one is that I believe that p, but it is not the case that p, and the second one is that p & I believe that not-p. Moore’s paradox is not a logical contradiction. Since if it is, the negation of the statement “p & I do not believe that p” would be an absolute truth, whereas in reality “not P & I believe that P” can not be guaranteed to be true. However, even if Moore’s paradox is not a logical contradiction, it is still absurd to assert sentences both in its commisive and omissive

Get Access