preview

Ethos In Poverty Inc

Decent Essays

Many of us would like to contribute to the greater good, one way or another. Charity and good deeds are an important part of our lives, which is encourage in our schools, churches, and college applications. We all want to give. We donate our clothes, food, and money, to help people in need, around the world. The problem is, we are a part of the problem. In the Film, Poverty, Inc., writer and director, Michael Matheson, addresses the problem with how poverty is handled on a global scale. The film effectively argues that paternalism is a disease, more than a cure, by using music, interviews, and factual evidence, as support. Poverty, Inc., reinforces the old saying, “If you give a man a fish, he will eat for a day, but if you teach a man to fish, …show more content…

An integral part of the film were the interviews and the information they relayed. These interviews provided appeals to ethos, and logos. Appeals to ethos were seen through interviews with Magatte Wade and Daniel Jean Lewis. Wade offered information regarding the ideas that Africa is poor or weak, and refuted it. Wades arguments appealed to ethos by questioning the ethics behind our yearning to help. Lewis also appealed to ethics by refusing the idea that we needed to help impoverished people, by sending them free stuff. Lewis’s argument works towards the appeal to ethics, because it attacks a capitalistic and western criticism. In the west, we often hear people criticize others for receiving, “handouts,” but we then send money to NGO’s to give people free stuff in other countries. The same logic should apply, though, therefore revealing the illogical approaches made by the west. The film appeals to logic by using statistics and facts in these interviews. Two examples of this are seen with Timothy Schwartz, and anthropologist in Haiti, and Hernando de Soto, an economist. Schwartz’s appeal comes from his explanation of the disproportionate import and export trade between Haiti and the United States. His explanation of the surplus’ being imported, killing local industry, creates and appeal to logic, between the film and the audience. Hernando De Soto’s argument works in a …show more content…

Throughout the world, it is a goal to end poverty, and we see examples of attempts to do so almost everywhere. The problem is that many of these attempts play into the industry, itself. We may not realize it, but we tend to support dependence instead of growth. Poverty, Inc. effectively shows the disease within the global poverty industry, by using music, interviews, and factual evidence to support the thesis that paternalism is the problem, not the solution. In the end, the film allows us to reevaluate our own roles in the industry, and better understand how we can be the cure, not the

Get Access