preview

Examples Of Peer Review Of Liat Greenwood

Decent Essays

Peer Review of Liat Greenwood
Cognition: Your proposition is not entirely clear. It seems like you're doing two or three different things that could be your proposition. I would say it may be worth your time to simplify the last few sentences of your introduction so that your proposition is more apparent. However, each of your reasons and the evidence are good. Make the proposition clear, and this will be an awesome literature review. Score: 3
Invention: This fits the genre of a literature review well. You do a great job of focusing on the field and how the authors from different fields have looked at and contributed to this new field. You stay away from focusing on the content of the articles and make sure that you're focused on the main idea …show more content…

Your footnotes are not showing up or you have not added them in yet. I'm not sure which, but I would check into it if they should be there by now. Also, In your last body paragraph, you don't have a clearly stated reason at the beginning (a topic sentence); maybe you want to consider adding one to prepare your readers for the evidence. Also, this paragraph is a little short in comparison with your other ones. I would consider adding some more evidence or explanation to the paragraph. Your conclusion is also short, but you acknowledge this. Score: …show more content…

You are using the content from the articles you cite to make a unique argument rather than talking about the field as a whole. Maybe consider focusing on how the authors are similar or differ in how they make their arguments or instead describe how the authors talking about incest have changed over time (for example, saying that at first scholars have shifted from focusing of the reason for nicest being maintaining the divine bloodline to it being keeping wealth and power within the family-not what you are saying but just an example). You have some elements of a literature review already in here, so the transition should not be a huge difference. Score:

Get Access