Risk and Return Analysis of FDI in Multi Brand Retail in India Ms. Anita Nyati, Lecturer (Business Administration) ABSTRACT Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) is the outcome of the mutual interest of multinational firms and host countries. The current debatable issue in India is whether to permit FDI in Multi Brand Retail (MBR) or not. This paper provides a study of various aspects of FDI in Multi Brand Retail. Firstly the paper examines the present set up of retail sector in India. Further it focuses on the benefits of FDI which are expected in terms of better quality, better technology, better customer services and infrastructural development of India. The paper also discusses the major concerns / risk associated in form of unemployment …show more content…
• Foreign investor should be the owner of the brand.Proposal for FDI in Multi Brand Retail (MBR)- • 51% FDI permission in MB retail. Minimum investment of $100 million. ................... ............... .................. Foreign investors should be the owner of the brand. • Now the issue is whether opening up of FDI in MBR will provide opportunities or create problems. There may be both side views so this paper presents an analysis. Before we list the benefits of FDI, it would be better to assess the present set up of the retail sector. Present set up of Indian Retail Sector - • In reference of the farmer- India is a country of farmers where 60% of population is involved ins with agriculture. India It is the 2nd largest producer of fruits & and vegetables and 3rd largest of grains. but Indian farmers are not getting enough returns. There are many 3-4 middle meninter-midiateriesmediatories in betweenbetween farmers and ultimate consumers. Even as per an estimate so farmers get only 2010 -3020 % of the actual price we pay. Major part of their crop goes wastage due to not having better logistic facility,facility; their produce can’t reach to the Mandies. In many parts of the country due to not getting enough money through farm produce farmers have to commit suicides, they go on the way to crimes. Migratecrimes, migrate to metro cities and live measurably in slums. According to a
This report is based on the comparison between two organizations that deals with the Retail Company that operates hypermarkets. The report consists of a comparison between Canadian business and Indian business. For this project I have chosen Canada’s Walmart and India’s D’mart the Canadian Walmart is the multinational retail corporation.And Indian D’mart deals within India only.
The retail division has accepted an awesome part all through the world in extending productivity of customer items and endeavors. It is similarly the second greatest industry in US to the extent amounts of agents and establishments. There is no denying the way that most of the made economies are particularly relying upon their retail territory as a prepare of advancement. The India Retail Industry is the greatest among each one of the organizations, speaking to more than 10 percent of the countries GDP and around 8 for every penny of the work. The Retail Industry in India has drawn nearer as a champion among the most dynamic and snappy paced organizations with a couple of players entering the market. Regardless, every one of them have not yet tasted accomplishment in perspective of the generous beginning hypotheses that are required to measure up to the underlying speculation with various
South Asia is one of the most densely populated regions of the world, where despite a slow growth, agriculture remains the backbone of rural economy as it employs one half to over 90 percent of the labor force. Both extensive and intensive policy measures for agriculture
But if we apply sociological imagination, we would realize that lack of government assistance, constant threats from money lenders, poor weather conditions, and Monsanto's costly and poor quality GMO seeds are some of the many reasons why farmers have lost their livelihoods and lands and are left on their own to struggle with starvation and misery (Barrette, 2014; Barromeo, 2012). According to Borromeo (2012), in 2006, 4,453 people committed suicide in an Indian state of Maharastra. That’s one every eight hours. Although farmers being in debt is not new and neither is suicide, what shocked me was not that people did it but how many people did it and why. "It was like a swathe of indebted farmers were trying to push the reset button because they felt they couldn’t make something work properly" (Borromeo,
• India's $250 billion retail business is the eighth largest in the world and has the potential to grow 7 per cent by 2011. [McKinsey Report] For a company already dominating the world markets, this is an un-passable opportunity.
In India, the middlemen between the producer and the retailer also played a prominent role in the retail and wholesale industries. Walmart’s proposal was to cut out these middlemen and to connect the producers directly to the retailers, in order to reduce the inefficiencies in India’s traditional supply chain. This was to be implemented through the joint venture, wherein Bharti would manage the retail store operations and Walmart would focus on logistics capabilities and building the supply chain. However, cutting out middlemen would create more opposition to Walmart’s presence in India. Notwithstanding the benefits that Walmart could bring to India, the retail lobby increased its protest against Walmart’s entry to the Indian retail
The population in India has brought positive effects for markets to increase economic growth. However, the increase demand to industrialize in rural communities around India would leave people to migrate to them and cause harm in their resources.
Wal-Mart will have to wait for some time before the Indian government is able to change the law that does not allow foreign, multi-brand retail stores to set up shop. These large retailers are seen as a threat to the small retailers dispersed amongst the country 's retail scene. These small retailers provide employment to tens of thousands of people which may become unemployed in the case that India allowed the entrance of large multi-brand companies. These rules don 't apply to the wholesale sector creating a loophole through which Wal-Mart may set up a joint venture with local companies such as Bharti Enterprises. The government allows 100 percent FDI in cash-and-carry operations and 51 percent in single brand operations. Wal-Mart would therefore have the opportunity to enter a cash-and-carry operation with a 50 percent stake.
Global food security has become one of the most prominent issues of the decade, as the world’s population, and thus the number of mouths to feed, is expected to reach 9.1 billion people by 2050. Despite growing income levels and overall economic growth, India continues to be one country that is severely affected by food insecurity, with a steady decline in calorie consumption per capita and a rise in levels of the population that have become food-insecure. Due to this confusing and contradictory nature of India’s food security condition, it has become significant in the realm of global food stability. Identifying the major reasons for food insecurity and the uneven impacts associated with food production in India, as well as opportunities for improvement within the country, are essential in hopes of understanding the nature of the global food crisis. While there are undoubtedly several reasons for current threats to food security, a close examination of the current social, economic, and environmental status of India demonstrates that a lack of crop diversification, climate change, and increasing westernization of Indian agricultural systems are three major contributors.
Global Retailing is one of the largest industry spread all over the globe, to meet needs of the consumers of all caste and religion. It is not necessary for a company to be physically to be present in the country to make transactions of goods or money. Instead, global retailers use the help of suppliers and local market to satisfy the needs. But now-a-days the trend is changing, retailers are now making and producing their own brand under their own shelter to meet their company’s respective motto and mission. When we talk about Global Retailers of International Retailers, we come across Walmart, Tesco, and Carrefour as the major industries responsible for Global Retailing. The grocery sale of top four retailers exceeded more than $600 billion in 2011, and I was forecasted to reach 2.5 times more in 2016. The Global Retailing operates in an oligopoly market because it is dominated by a few suppliers in the market.
Wal- Mart in order to capture the Indian market is trying to introduce low price strategy on their products which inturn affect the other local businesses. Local traders later also should implement this pricing strategy which may affect their profit margin. But in return the consumers may benefit a lot from this. Due to the entry of Wal –Mart into the Indian market the competition may increase between local retailing businesses like Pantaloon, Reliance etc. we can see a tough competition between these business units in future . From the analysis there is advantages and disadvantages for Wal-Mart to enter in the Indian retailing system. From the arrival of the Wal-Mart to India FDI will be increased in India and most of the retail stores will have the subsidiaries in many of the places to increase the availability of the customers. Most of the foreign retail outlets is
FDI in Retailing started with FDI in cash and carry wholesale trading first permitted in 1997 to the extent of 100% under the Government approval route and thereafter in 2006 brought under the automatic route. In 2006 again FDI in Single Brand Retailing was permitted to the extent of 51%. From here it is but natural and logical that FDI would now proliferate to multi-brand retailing. But the progression to FDI in multi-brand retailing cannot take place at the cost of vital concerns raised in connection with this possible change by different groups; viz, the question of adaptability of the retailers in the unorganized sector, the question as to how the FDI in retailing can be harnessed for the benefits of Indian agriculture and Medium and Small Enterprise and above all how to impart into the economy a degree of resilience to withstand the changes that would be ushered in the wake of introduction of FDI in retailing. All these concerns have to be addressed not because the Left wing political parties and the media through their campaign have necessitated such attention but because we are constitutionally bound to do so .The Preamble of the Constitution resolves to constitute India into a Sovereign, Socialist, Secular, Democratic, Republic and to secure to all its citizens JUSTICE, social, economic and political …..EQUALITY of status and opportunity. Directive Principles of State Policy similarly exhorts the state to establish just, equitable and fair order. Article 39(c) states that the state should ensure that the operation of the economic system does not result in the concentration of wealth and means of production to the common detriment. Though both these features are not enforceable, the Executive and the Apex Court in particular have
As 70% of employment is coming from the agriculture sector, hence this form of retailing is mostly seen in those areas and of course to some part of urban India there is a lot of ups and downs for opening of sector for direct investment from the foreign players but government cannot neglect the interest of small players. One of main reason for not opening this sector to FDI is it may decrease the employment in the Unorganized sector and increase the
Foreign brands whose outlets are opening up in India as per the norms, where the Government is allowing up to 100% FDI in single-brand retail and 51% FDI in multi-brand retail.
First of all, the foreign direct investment is an international movement of capital made by a company or by other entity to establish a subsidiary or to affiliate abroad, by acquiring an interest in a foreign company, by merging with a company foreign, or by establishing a joint venture in another country (O 'Neill, 2004). The FDI will allow Wal-Mart to expand their operations into the Moroccan market, to increase its productivity, and to increase its turnover. By merging with Marjane Corporation in Morocco, Wal-Mart will benefit from the proximity of consumers, from the key markets, from certain benefits comparative like a cheaper labor or a more skilled work, transport and communication, other infrastructure, and from a competitive tax and regulatory framework. Moreover, Wal-Mart Corporation can also invest in Morocco to better manage their global supply networks of the production and distribution to ensure its access to essential resources. Furthermore, the FDI can also be an important catalyst for economic development and prosperity of Morocco. Finally, the FDI has the dual benefit of creating jobs and new sources of tax revenue in both developed economies and in developing economies. In addition, there will be effects such as increased demand for local services and the transmission of knowledge of expatriate managers to local workers. Nevertheless, for businesses that invest and operate in a foreign environment can be confronted to significant challenges, especially if