preview

Forging The New World: A History By Christopher Columbus

Decent Essays

I found our Tuesday class to be very informative on human nature. It is easy to say that the Spanish were "evil" for their treatment of the indigenous people; however, I'm afraid that statement is too black and white. When dealing with humans in regards to history or any subject matter black and white simply does not work. Human history is a full spectrum and in order to categorize a historical event we must first understand the inner-workings that lead up to this point. We need to understand the thought process behind European entitlement. Columbus' and Ferdinand's letters were crucial in revealing the nature of the Spanish mindset. Columbus spends a great deal of time describing how welcoming the indigenous people were to both him and his men "they believe that all strength, all power, in …show more content…

At the time, all that was known about the indigenous people was that they lacked modern development, that they lived more primitively, and that their customs were vastly dissimilar to that of the Spaniards and therefore inferior. Furthermore, James Carter and Richard Warren's book, Forging the Modern World: A History, implements the use of maps that show the distance between Spain and the new world which may have impeded proper decision making as information from the new world was delayed by months. Chapter 2 excellently maps out the various motives the Spaniards had in regards to competition with other countries attempting to colonize and there was a global tragedy of the commons, missionary work for the Roman Catholic Church (which had so much authority with monarchies), and ultimately limited knowledge that led to miscommunication and (by today's standards) poor judgement. In conclusion when the puzzle pieces are placed in such an order it is easy to understand the Spaniards' perception of entitlement and it is made harder to dismiss the Spaniards as simply

Get Access