preview

France, China

Decent Essays

Intertwined with France’s continual change to government and Republics is their culture of desiring a hero. After the French revolution, Napoleon was voted in as the emperor of France. Napoleon was a war hero after the French revolution and the citizens of France believed he could be the savior that France needed. Because of the hero-worship culture in France, Napoleon was given dictatorial powers. Additionally, the French citizens showed the yearning for a savior after World War Two when General Charles de Gaulle became head of the government. In 1958 the French generals demanded that de Gaulle be named head of the government, and if not they would land paratroopers in Paris and take over the city. The president had no choice and the parliament …show more content…

China has had twelve different constitutions since 1911. The most recent constitution came to be in 1982, and in theory it gives a serious amount of power to the National People’s Congress (NPC). The NPC is a group that is elected by the provincial people’s assemblies who are in turn elected by lowering ranking officials. The constitution states that the NPC is “the highest Organ of state power”. The constitution also gives the NPC the power to “amend the constitution; supervise its enforcement; enact and amend laws; ratify and abrogate treaties; approve the state budget and plans for national economic and social development; elect and impeach top officials of the state and judiciary; and supervise the work of the State Council, the State Central Military Commission, the Supreme People’s Court, and the Supreme People’s Procuratorate”. However, in reality the NPC serves mostly as a rubber stamp for Party decisions. One example of this is the NPC’s right to elect party officials such as the President and Vice President. Technically the NPC has these rights, it is the CPC that actually appoints these positions and the NPC just simply agrees with the Party’s decisions. A driving reason that the NPC has so much theoretical power, yet does not have any power in reality is that many NPC deputies are members of the CPC or are state officials or civil servants. China rejects the principle of separation of power, and this allows for NPC deputies to hold positions in these other branches of government. The NPC is designed to oversee the other branches of government that they are usually in, therefore, many members of the NPC are overseeing themselves. According to a leading Chinese media organization, 85% of the three thousand NPC members hold positions in other branches of the government. That number clearly shows why the NPC does not use any of their power, because they are overseeing

Get Access