preview

Gender Roles In David Fincher's Fight Club

Decent Essays

David Fincher’s Fight Club, 1999, contains strong themes of masculinity and enforced gender roles. It is subjective, however, whether or not the gender narrative within the film complies with modern feminist values, or serves as nothing more than masculine empowerment. The two critical texts I have chosen to study are Masculinity in Crisis and Private Satisfactions and Public Disorders: Fight Club, Patriarchy, and the Politics of Masculine Violence, both of which analyse Fight Club through a feminist lens. My first critical text views the film as a feminist statement on the toxicity of masculine violence, while my second text finds more faults with the gender roles in the film.

In the section Masculinity in Crisis of an online text analyzing Fight Club (Violence as a Reclamation of Masculinity in the Postmodern Moment), the author states that Fight Club is a deliberate commentary on male victimization as a result of postmodernism and second wave feminism. The testicular cancer support group and the character of Bob represent the loss of traditional masculinity in American society. Later, the violence …show more content…

However, one text states that the film intentionally contains this masculine sadism, as it makes a statement on its toxicity and eventually shows the narrator’s transcendence from the traditional male role (represented in his fight with Tyler). In contrast, the second text declares that the violence and entitlement exuded by the men in Fight Club is not portrayed critically or in a negative light. Giroux believes that the violence in the film is unhealthily glorified and incredibly misogynistic as it shows only males in their traditionally virile and violent role, shunning femininity in order to “cleanse” themselves. The two texts, while they both focus on gender roles within Fight Club, hold different views on their

Get Access