preview

George Bell Sparknotes

Decent Essays

In his essay “The Lonely Death of George Bell,” N.R. Kleinfeld describes how life goes on after people die and they are survived by their belongings and memories they gave to people. Kleinfield illustrates how even melancholy deaths can affect society in positive and negative ways. Although he chose an interesting topic to discuss, N.R. Kleinfield’s essay failed to be captivating because it contained monotonous, unnecessary detail and had a disconnected thesis. Kleinfield starts out the story at the scene of the death, the body freshly discovered by the police. Then, Kleinfield goes on to discuss his thesis that every death can cause “ripples” (273) of change throughout a vast distance. First, Kleinfield describes what it takes to pronounce the man dead and identify him. Kleinfield then talks about the time and effort the man who works at the morgue takes to secure a proper funeral and resting place for this stranger. Kleinfield talks about the cleaners that come in to clean the mess in George’s apartment, the people who take inventory of George’s belongings, and the people who find homes for the items across vast distances. Kleinfield discusses a new stance about Georges life and the people involved in the will. Finally, Kleinfield goes on to describe how each of them knew George and which ones were still alive.

A great deal of the paper is comprised of dull facts. Kleinfield’s writing sounds like he just asked a bunch of questions and wrote them down with exactly every detail he could. For example, “He consulted the mirror and blended into the next lane” (283). It seems as though Kleinfield has taken a mainly closed stance on the paper. When Kleinfield says, “A transport team from the medical examiner’s office drove it to the morgue at Queens Hospital Center, where it was deposited in one of some 100 refrigerated drawers, cooled to 35 degrees” (274) it demonstrates my point that this paper sounds factual. It doesn’t matter what temperature the drawer is or how many drawers there are. Kleinfield mentions the weather, scenery, and day in the following quote, “In the frosty gloom of Dec. 30, as a hissing wind spun litter through the air…” (284). We are bombarded by these unnecessary facts Kleinfield

Get Access