preview

Hannah Arendt Totalitarianism

Better Essays

Ideology or Terror
“In Discussion: Hannah Arendt’s View of Totalitarianism”

What is totalitarianism? Totalitarianism is commonly mistaken as tyranny or a dictatorship. It begins as tyranny to lift the boundaries of the laws, but then turns into something stronger. According to Hannah Arendt on page 86, “If it is true that the elements of totalitarianism can be found by retracing the history and analyzing the political implications of what we usually call the crisis of our century, then the conclusion is unavoidable that the crisis is no mere threat from the outside, no mere result of some aggressive foreign policy of wither Germany or Russia, and that it will no more disappear with the death of Stalin that it disappeared with the fall of …show more content…

This claim, which is only now, over fifty years later, being empirically tested, accords with the view of some scholars of genocide that genocide and colonialism are inherently linked. German Southwest Africa (Namibia), where the Herero and Nama War (1904-08) ended in the first genocide of the twentieth century, is often cited as the best proof of Arendt's thesis. Yet Arendt herself argued that there were unbridgeable breaks between the nineteenth-century, including the history of imperialism, and twentieth-century totalitarianism, and also believed that the Holocaust could not meaningfully be compared with pre-modern or colonial cases of genocide.” Totalitarian government has been around for years and will continue to be here for many more. Hannah Arendt’s Ideology and Terror: …show more content…

After reading Hannah Arendt’s view on totalitarian government I can agree with Donoghue. Denis Donoghue wrote this after reading Arendt’s work. Donoghue explains, “One of the most disturbing implications in Hannah Arendt's books is that there are facts, situations, events with which the human imagination cannot cope. I had always assumed that the imagination was good enough for anything, and I had been delighted by Stevens's picture of reality and the imagination in dynamic poise, the violence within grappling with that other violence which is its occasion, its challenge. Dynamic accord; reality and the imagination equal and inseparable. But Hannah Arendt is right; the human imagination is dazed by the reality of the concentration camps; it staggers, doubts its own evidence, lurches in torpor or hysteria. It cannot disclose the real.” This is basically saying that our imagination is not always good situations like people think they are. Your imagination can be used for evil just like everything else can be. “The inhabitants of a totalitarian country are thrown into and caught in the process of nature or history for the sake of accelerating its movement; as such, they can only be executioners or victims of its inherent law. The process may decide that those who today eliminate races and individuals or the members of dying classes and decadent peoples are tomorrow those who must be sacrificed. What

Get Access