Jaiden Rodriguez Honors Analysis Essay In V for Vendetta the James McTeigue film and Novel from George Orwell depicted on a masked vigilante ¨aka V¨ takes up arms using terrorist acts against a fascist government that abuses privacy and shows a dictatorship type government that rules against the people that live in this society. The masked man ¨V¨ What the author is trying to warn about the misuse of technology in this film and novel is that Privacy is an aspect of life that is abused, and violated. He thinks that one’s right to privacy is viewed as the ability to keep aspects and tangents of life close to one’s self. ¨V¨ follows a saying made by a person in the society a long time ago on the 5th of November that promotes an equitable country. ¨More than 400 years ago a great citizen wished to embed the 5th of November forever in our memory. His hope was to remind the world that fairness, justice, and freedom are more than words. They are perspectives¨ ( ¨V¨) With this the 5th of November has came around and the government has received a sign from ¨V¨ when he blew up the statue Madam Justice and the Old bailey which symbolized freedom. He destroyed these places because the society does not …show more content…
¨This violent and unparalleled assault on our security will not go undefended. Or unpunished! Our enemy is an insidious one, seeking to divide us and destroy the very foundation of our great nation. Those caught tonight in violation of curfew will be considered in league with our enemy and will be prosecuted as a terrorist and without exception and without mercy.¨ (Dictator High Chancellor )This shows that the government does not want the people to know or fight for what they are trying to hide and that is they have no privacy and they cant keep things to
In the book, Orwell shows how people are affected by the telescreens when Winston says “It was terribly dangerous to let your thoughts wander when you were in any public place or within range of a telescreen.” (Orwell ) This suggests that the Party’s surveillance tactics are so advanced that even your thoughts might betray you and get you into trouble. It also shows that people have lost any sense of freedom that they previously had. The implications of this are that the government is forcefully manipulating the people so as to avoid any rebellious behavior but in the process, it has also taken away their privacy. The idea of being heard or watched by something when you think that you have privacy is something that has traveled through time and still exists today. An example in modern American society could be how the brand-new Alexa is said to “record snippets of what you say in the privacy of your home and store it on Amazon servers.” (Tsukayama) This shows how even in modern times that there are means that might be used to spy on people and keep track of what they say and do. This is important because an American society that is said to be democratic and free still has a sense of secrecy and loss of privacy. The people in this society should find it troubling that they don’t have privacy the same way that people in a totalitarian regime had lost their freedom.
The general public gives an problem with the government surveillance as a media for invading others privacy. With the government monitoring, collecting, and retaining people's personal data, one side would claim that it is an infringement of their freedom to the rights to privacy. While the National security associations justifies the reason for monitoring would be to maintain order. Their ways to maintain order would be to monitor criminal and terrorist activity and to detect incoming threats, terrorists, or problems that would harm their country. This issue shows that freedom cannot exist without order. Although the general public wants their freedom of their privacy, they can not achieve their most of their desires because it puts their lives at risk without protection. Order is necessary in order to have freedom. It is impossible to attain entire freedom for a cause, however, it is possible to attain freedom to a certain
Of the many symbolic masks, the Guy Fawkes mask stands out as one of the most effective, often being used as a “masked identity” in order to make profound statements. Not only does this secret identity create more attention to the “masked one” but it also diverts attention to the cause rather than the identity. Literally using a mask, Fawkes was the main influence of the character “V”, in James McTeigue’s, V For Vendetta. V’s connections and motivations to Guy Fawkes, his attempt to justify himself as a terrorist, and V’s concealment of his true identity, collectively define the message that V conveys to his audience: to break parliament and take control of their own country.
The right to privacy acts as a common controversial topic in the world today. The American government is constantly battling between its limits as well as responsibilities to protect its citizens. Outside of America, however, privacy is a right that not all other countries grant their citizens. In the novels Fahrenheit 451 by Ray Bradbury and 1984 by George Orwell, the right to privacy is a recurring theme provoked by the role of technology in relation to governmental restriction and responsibility, as well as the lack of personal freedoms in these worlds.
In the novel 1984, George Orwell uses imagery and word choice to demonstrate how much people value their privacy. This is proven when the citizens learn that the Police Patrol and the government are spying on them in their homes without them knowing. George Orwell states that he knows there is someone snooping in his windows all the time. Night or day, it does not matter. He knows for a fact they are watching his every move. This goes to show that the Police Patrol and government have no boundaries and do not respect their citizens privacy in any way. They are trying to catch them doing anything they are not supposed to be doing. Everybody should feel safe when they are in their home. No one wants to always feel like someone is constantly
As a growing topic of discussion, privacy in our society has stirred quite some concern. With the increase of technology and social networking our standards for privacy have been altered and the boundary between privacy and government has been blurred. In the article, Visible Man: Ethics in a World Without Secrets, Peter Singer addresses the different aspects of privacy that are being affected through the use of technology. The role of privacy in a democratic society is a tricky endeavor, however, each individual has a right to privacy. In our society, surveillance undermines privacy and without privacy there can be no democracy.
He offers the general population an opportunity to beat their apprehension and commend a day with him by exploding the parliament building. Gradually individuals start to understand that this event may really happen. They understand that they have been deprived of free will and that they are going to get the opportunity to be free once again. V vowed to blow up parliament and had the country’s support. The people of England were set free, and V was their hero. On page 188 in the book, a girl is seen spray painting the government’s poster with V’s symbol on
In support of privacy, Daniel J. Solove wrote, Why Privacy Matters Even If You Have ‘Nothing to Hide.’ Solove begins his argument by introducing the nothing-to-hide argument. In general, the argument for surveillance is ‘if you’ve got nothing to hide, you’ve got nothing to fear:’ hence people’s support for government efforts and regulations to ‘protect’ citizens by decreasing privacy. Those who object this argument target its most extreme cases. For example, if you have nothing to hide, could I take a nude picture of you, own all entitlements to the photo, and share it with anyone? Absolutely not, most would say, but this objection is not exceptionally compelling according to Solove. In order to understand privacy, we must not reduce it to one single definition. Privacy is extremely complex and involves a range of different things that share common characteristics. For instance, one’s privacy can be invaded by the expose of your innermost secrets, but it may also be invaded if a peeping Tom (without the reveal of any secrets) is observing you. Your privacy may also be invaded if the government seeks extensive information about you. All of these examples cause harm related to an invasion of privacy, thus making the definition of privacy not applicable for a “one size fits all” conclusion. The underlying and most significant harm that comes from surveillance is the problem of information processing. Solove uses The Trial example to demonstrate this effect. Here, the
It’s a title with a strong letter used as somewhat like a alliteration to exaggerate the ideas within this film, ‘V for Vendetta’, directed by James McTeigue, this defines what the true meaning of injustice which seems to be over exaggerated through action, sci-fi and thriller scenes. ‘V for Vendetta’ is a type of film where in a future, where there was a British tyranny or corruption in the government, a shadowy freedom fighter plots to overthrow it with the help of a young woman. This film shows the message of the best advice is to stop fighting it and embrace the fact that you have been given an opportunity if you chose to view it with a different set of eyes. And yet there will be many who miss this opportunity as they feel a false sense of security operating in the belief systems that harbor fear, anger and hate rather than letting go to face the very emotions that enslave them.This film uses fancy quotes or catch phrases, with a strong act of violence in acting around the main character(s), especially the protagonist ‘V’ and to the eventuality, ‘Evey’ at the end of the story. Special effects and the fanatical costume visuals (with the famous Guy Fawkes mask) all is used intently to make the audience with a tint of exhilarance, to make them think, what does this mean? What is the idea that V is trying to show in injustice? Through elements found in the film I’ve found that,......
In the film V for Vendetta the viewer is welcomed to a dystopia in which the government not only controls its citizens, but removes their privacy, civil
Almost everything someone does in today’s society is under surveillance. It does not matter if you are surfing the web, going to the store, or even driving a car; it is almost always under surveillance. While Michel Foucault does not specifically talk about modern surveillance technology in Discipline & Punish (1977), much of the primitive technology that he does talk about is directly related with today’s surveillance technology. Michel Foucault believes that societal surveillance began to take effect during the 1600’s to control the masses. Many modern surveillance technologies reflect Foucault’s ideas helping to categorize, differentiate, hierarchize, and exclude people from the masses.
“Remember, remember, the fifth of November, the gunpowder treason and plot. I know of no reason why the gunpowder treason should ever be forgot.” This inspirational quote made by V in V for Vendetta, originates from Guy Fawkes plot to blow up the British Parliament building and, in an act of protest, assassinate King James I and return a Catholic monarch to the British throne. In the UK today, November 5th is celebrated as Guy Fawkes Day, and is the equality to the US Halloween. Guy Fawkes effigies are hung and burned, just as Americans hang scarecrows and other scary idols. However, there is one main difference between the two, one is a political holiday and the other a day of scares.
Alan Moore was the author to the book “v for vendetta” and the director to the movie version was James Mcteigue now if it has the same plot is a question that I am going to answer for you. Alan Moore was the creator of v for vendetta and it was a very popular novel the novel was published in the year 1988. The movie came in a later time and was directed by James Mcteigue and released in 2005. Now when the movie was being made Alan Moore did not participate in the script writing and asked Brothers the producer of the movie to not include him in any promotional material and the reasoning for this is he had no part in writing the script or guiding James Mcteigue on writing the script. His reasoning is that he does not agree with most
"People should not be afraid of their governments. Governments should be afraid of their people." V for Vendetta is an action packed thriller that involves lots of intense scenes and follows a great storyline. This film does an awesome job of keeping you on the edge of your seat throughout. This movie is great in showing that the people are powerful and can be in charge, if they put their minds to it.
2a) Describe the differences between the fascist Norsefire government’s and V’s anarchist view of a “healthy country.” How do Norsefire and V define the role of the government and the role of the citizen differently?