preview

Housing First and Substance Abuse

Better Essays

RUNNING HEAD: RESEARCH ARTICLE ANALYSIS

Research Article Analysis

The research article I chose to analyze, Housing First Services for People who Are Homeless with Co-Occurring Serious Mental Illness and Substance Abuse, studied the outcomes of alcohol and substance abuse as well as participation in substance abuse and mental health treatment between people in housing first programs and treatment first programs in New York City. The two research questions asked were, “Are there group differences in alcohol and drug use at 48 months?” and “Are there group differences in participation in substance abuse and mental health treatment at 48 months?” (Padgett, Gulcur, & Tsemberis, 2006, p. 76). The purpose of this study was to find out …show more content…

There was no hypothesis stated by the authors as to whether their research would or would not resemble NYHS’s study, however the authors probably did hypothesize that the same results would transpire over a longer period of time.
The independent variable in this study was whether people were placed in the housing first program, or the treatment first program. The treatment first program served as the control group, whereas the housing first participants became the experimental group. The dependent variable was alcohol and drug use, rates of participation in substance abuse and mental health treatment, and whether housing was maintained at 48 months (Padgett et al., 2006). The authors did not use a theoretical framework, but as I purposed, this research resembles systems theory. I believe that the variance in regulations of housing (requirements of sobriety and participation in treatment) are the defining elements in whether participants were able to maintain housing or not at the end of 48 months. Again, there was no official hypothesis stated in the article, but the data suggests three things. First, if a participant was in the housing first program, then participation in substance abuse and mental health treatment was lower, which is a negative direction of association. Second, if a participant was in the housing first program, they

Get Access