preview

How Is Martha Presented In Johnny Got His Gun

Decent Essays

Continuing Comfort The way lives are affected by others is not something that can be explained easily. People everywhere have an affect on everyone they meet by the impression and legacy that they left behind, especially when families are affected by the absence of a loved one, like mothers. This effect is demonstrated in Johnny Got His Gun, written by Dalton Trumbo and Shenandoah, directed by Andrew McLaglen. In both stories there is an absence of the mother's. In Shenandoah, Martha had died while giving birth to Boy, the youngest of the seven children. Even though Martha is dead she leaves her impression on her family in many different ways. Unlike Martha, Macia is not dead. Macia is the mother of the main character Joe in Johnny Got His …show more content…

In the movie Shenandoah, we see that even after sixteen years of Martha being gone, she still has a spot at the table all set up as if she were there to eat with them. The Andersons also go to church, in the movie Charlie says ¨It's what Martha wanted.¨(Shenandoah). Contrary to Martha, Macia doesn't make an impact on Joe's actions, but the memories that he has of his mother makes him think about things differently. ¨His mother before she was his mother before she thought particularly of becoming his mother would go over to the piano the only one on Cole Creek and play the Beautiful Blue Ohio or perhaps My Pretty Red Wing.¨(Trumbo 13). In the book, this affects the way Joe thinks about things because he remembers his mother's music. When Joe remembers his mother with music, it is a way that he is able to connect with her and remember her when he is injured from the war. Similarly, they are both able to feel further connected to their mothers through the memories and reminders that they are there with them. Differently, in Shenandoah, the son who had a wife has a daughter in the movie and they name the baby Martha, after the …show more content…

¨His mother was singing in the kitchen. He could hear her singing there and the sound of her voice was the sound of home.¨(Trumbo 15) As Joe remembers his mother singing in the kitchen it reminds him of home, so even when he doesn't know where he is it provides him comfort remembering that. Similarly in Shenandoah, Charlie is shown talking to her grave. At the end of the movie, after they had all gotten back he makes a comment when he is talking to her grave. ¨I don't know what else to say about the war¨(Shenandoah). Charlie finds comfort when talking to Martha's grave because it makes him feel like she is still there with him. Differently, Macia provides comfort when Joe is calling for his mom in his sleep. ¨Mother where are you? Hurry mother hurry hurry hurry and wake me up. I'm having a nightmare mother where are you? Hurry mother. I'm down here.¨(Trumbo 63). Joe is calling out towards his mother to come and save him because he feels comfort being able to feel her

Get Access