preview

Humor In Basic Clinical Skills By Melvin Konner

Decent Essays

Melvin Konner, in “Basic Clinical Skills”, uses a first person point of view along with some bits of humor in order to establish a more relatable narrator. He discusses several topics such as the relationship between doctors and their patients, the healthcare given in hospitals, and the role that the physician plays in different contexts of life. Konner begins the piece by describing how the narrator was older than his peers. Being older, and not as “naïve” as his peers, did not work in his favor. Instead, he overthought his every move. I thought that this was interesting because typically, the older you get, the wiser and more self-aware you should become. While on a visit to a rehabilitation hospital, he saw a quadriplegic patient. He noticed …show more content…

When he first visited the surgical ward, it was described as brilliant, it even seemed to glitter. However, that too good to be true varnish was soon tainted. Konner uses juxtaposition in order to emphasize how the narrator felt indignant. When the middle-aged woman was getting a central line put in, all Konner could focus on was how the woman moaned “mama, mama”. All the while, the medical student had a “cheery lilting tone with a fresh expression on her face”. The woman was described as frail, small, and a tangle of orange her- making her seem all the more desperate and pained. Her repeated moans for “mama” were a cry for help… a cry that nobody responded to. When the central line was put in, the narrator was aggravated by the resident’s reaction- they cheered about the fact that they succeeded in completing the procedure, but failed to listen to the patient’s cries (“her resistance was treated as an annoyance and her cries were ignored”). When the residents left, the narrator stroked the patient’s hair and told her that everything was going to be alright. The woman didn’t respond to the narrator’s touch. He thought that his actions might have been useless, but it didn’t necessarily mean that he shouldn’t have been making them. This behavior represents the good nature of the narrator’s soul- despite the fact that everyone around him failed to show compassion for the woman, he did. The narrator described the second lesson as realizing that “humane acts not directly affecting ‘care’… acts and gestures that are other than completely instrumental. That entire last paragraph entices me. The term “care” is far removed from what it once meant. It now refers to the medicinal approach to illness. The human nature of hospital care is being removed as healthcare has shifted to serving more people in shorter amounts of time. Today, that problem is rarely addressed. It’s as if

Get Access