preview

I Am Not A Patriot Analysis

Good Essays

Why I Am Not a Patriot
(Terms and Conditions May Apply)

Standard dictionaries define patriotism as a “love for or devotion to one's country.” While this offers a succinct introduction to the notion of patriotism, a comprehensive account of the subject extends well beyond the scope of any singular definition. In his defense of “Modern Patriotism,” Stephen Nathanson addresses the hesitation that people face when forced to adopt or reject the “patriot” label. Indeed, the modern conception of a patriot carries implications of blind allegiance and excessive nationalism. Alternatively, “to say that one is not a patriot suggests that one lacks the loyalty appropriate to citizens.” I open this discussion with the inner-dialogue I faced when asked …show more content…

While jingoism promotes a “my country right or wrong” approach, true patriotism demands an objective appraisal of a “child’s” actions. And so, we arrive at our first distinction which is to be understood as a matter of conditional loyalty: the patriot and the jingoist share a similar “love for or devotion to one’s country,” however the patriot’s notion leaves room for “loyal opposition.” Author Igor Primoratz dubs this type of loyalty, as “value-based” patriotism. In his essay “On Patriotism,” George Kateb challenges the validity of the parent-child metaphor as a means to better understand patriotism. The historian argues that a comparison of a “country to a parent is [like] performing an act of imagination… the metaphor facilitates an exploitable mental confusion.” However cynical Kateb’s views on patriotism may be, he paves the way to a worthy query: what, or who is the object of a patriots love and devotion? Idealists, would likely profess their loyalty belongs to a utopian notion of America, while I choose to believe that a country is defined by its …show more content…

While few advocates of patriotism would argue against the value of adopting patriotic beliefs, the touchstone of patriotism involves a readiness to act for your country. Kateb interprets this as “ a readiness to die and to kill,” for one’s country. However, his claims can be easily countered; even if full-fledged patriotism does involve a willingness to die for one’s country it is not defined by it. Instead a true patriot promises to uphold and advance a set of principles, even when his country does not. The U.S. supreme court notes that “an informed public is the most potent of all restraints upon misgovernment.” After all, patriotism, however social in nature, is a political

Get Access