The Importance Of Broad-Based Consultation
There is a direct and intended correlation between thorough and extensive consulta-tions and resulting strong, compelling report recommendations that stakeholders can stand behind and support; and that ultimately governments will move quickly to imple-ment. When those consulted and the constituencies they represent can see their contributions and issues reflected in the final report and recommendations, they are much more likely to press governments for the implementation of said recommendations.
From inception, my objective was to develop and implement a consultation strategy and process for this Review that would be robust, broad-based and balanced; one that would provide both current and
…show more content…
It was critically important for me to make sure that we were also well enough resourced to take the requisite time to consult as fully and widely as possible. Another significant element of our consultation strategy was an emphasis on remaining flexible. This allowed us the time as a team to remain nimble enough to course correct and reschedule in order to accommodate new consultation requests and proposals, stakeholder generated postponements, and receive follow-up information pertinent to the report content and recommendations.
Who We Heard From
Over the course of our almost 7 month consultation process, my Review team and I met with over 1,442 individuals in more than 125 private meetings and 18 public consulta-tions across Ontario, Canada and the United Kingdom. We consulted with affected families; policing stakeholders, including police associations, commissioners, chiefs of police and police service boards; Black and other radicalized communities, including Somali, Muslim and newcomer communities; on and off-reserve Indigenous communities and Inuit communities, including chiefs, elders, band members, Self-Administered First Nation Police Services representatives, and service providers; provincial and international government agencies and officials; experts and academics; mental health practitioners and survivors/consumers; youth and youth workers; LGBTQ representatives; women’s organizations; as well as the
The PICO model (see Table 1) was used to design a research question for assessing the Appraisal of Guidelines, and to develop an effective evidence-based process. Springett & Campbell (2006) have underlined the importance that to formulate a good question the four components are required. These components include an identified of population; an intervention; a comparison point and an outcome.
Gaines, L. K., & Kappeler, V. E. (2014). Policing in america (8th ed.). (S. Decker-Lucke, Ed.) Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, United States of America: Anderson Publishing. Retrieved January 2017
Policing is a very difficult, complex and dynamic field of endeavor that is always evolves as hard lessons teach us what we need to know about what works and what don’t work. There are three different Era’s in America’s policing: The Political Era, The Reform Era, and The Community Problem Solving Era. A lot has changed in the way that policing works over the years in the United States.
There are always key elements to assessments and reviews, including the family and friends. Everyone has a responsibility to support individuals and bearing in mind ‘need to know’ information. The aim being able to achieve the highest goal to maintain effective open channels for everyone.
keep the work on track, and can let you know if things are going according to plan.
I am a Member of the Toronto Police Black Community Constitutive Committee (BCCC), where my main role is educating the police on strategies to engage with the youths, adding an anti-oppressive lens. Am also the Vice Chair of the Social Work Students’ Union; and a mentor, and lead mentor in the Tri-Mentoring program. I have made a personal vow to help create a legacy of change and a sense of community where everyone is welcomed, loved and accepted. I am motivated and driven to help the Social Work program and the Faculty of community, achieve our vision, which is to challenge the status quo and create meaningful change.
The task force has several recommendation for how to build up trust and legitimacy. The first recommendation calls for police to change their mindset. Police need to not be seen as an occupying force. A citizen, Rufus Scales, who was affected by the racial profiling stated in the New York Times article that “whenever one of them is near, I don’t feel comfortable. I don’t feel safe.” As a member of the community he does not view the police a guardian but that they are against him. To fix this issue the police need to adopt a guardian mindset.
Police organizations across Canada must improve by implementing new community policing strategies to foster a healthy relationship with the population, and must include mandatory ‘cultural sensitivity training’ for all officers. This will be vital in understanding the post-colonial impacts of residential schools, such as intergenerational effects, thus improving their responses to situational exigencies.
The justice department today is spending millions of dollars to better train the police department against bias and examine law enforcement procedures, known as community policing. Community policing has been slowing evolving over the years. The civil rights movement exposed how weak the system was in the 1960’s. The development of the model has been inspired by
Whilst we as practitioners do everything we can to achieve this it is important that we contact and utilise other professionals if needed to help us achieve these outcomes.
No community in Canada comes into conflict with criminal justice system officials more disproportionately than Aboriginals (Dickson-Gilmore, 2011, p.77). Indeed, Aboriginal Canadians are often subject to both overt and unintended discrimination from Canadian law enforcement due in large part to institutionalized reputations as chronic substance abusers who are incapable of reform (Dickson-Gilmore, 2011, p.77-78). One of the more startling contemporary examples of this is the case of Frank Paul; a Mi’kmaq Canadian who was left to die in a Vancouver alley by officers of the Vancouver Police Department after being denied refuge in a police “drunk tank”. Not surprisingly, this event garnered significant controversy and public outcry amongst
There is a major negative hole in the relationship between police and the indigenous community; Blagg and Cunneen both convey key relevant statistics that, display relative evidence of a negative relationship between the two groups. Both authors also state past strategies that have been used to identify these issues and work to heal the relationship. The authors also state present strategies that are being used and ideas that could help mend the relationship that has been torn apart between the two groups.
Although many may find community policing and problem-oriented policing to fall in the same category, there is (surprisingly) a difference between the two. For one, community policing has many definitions. For some, it means instituting foot and bicycle patrols and doing acts pertaining to the ideal bond between police officers and their community. While for others it means maintaining order and cleaning up neighborhoods in desperate need of repair (Dunham & Alpert, 2005). However, an idyllic definition of community policing is altering the traditional definition of crime control to community problem-solving and promising to transform the way police do their job. Within the past two decades, there has been much research on community
There is recent controversy over police use of force, especially in minority communities such as in African American communities, Hispanic communities, and other publics with large populations of minorities. Increased levels of force among these communities have created challenges for police departments. These challenges include a lack of trust from the community towards law enforcement officers and an absence of respect creating situations that lead to police use of force. There are already various programs in place that attempt to decrease this challenge by educating the public, respecting one another, and giving those who were on the wrong track second chances. A combination of these solutions and the implementation of more of them would decrease the number of contacts between police and minorities that lead to the use of force (Roberg & Novak, 2014).
It has been consistently shown in research that minorities are more likely to be mistreated by the police compared to other people (Dunnaville, 2000). Recent incidents have seen the police use excessive force on people and mistreat minorities. As such, the legitimacy of the police has been put under scrutiny and questioned. Many communities in the United States have demonstrated in reaction to recent incidents of police misconduct and excessive use of force. The people have lost trust in the police because of these issues. The police force has been accused of mistreating people, sexual harassment, violent and careless arrests among people particularly the minorities. As demonstrated in the movie ‘Policing the Police’ police officers are seen mistreating people for instance the scene where the police sexually harassed a teenager by touching sensitive areas. Community members are not willing to trust or work with the police to fight crime. As such, it is critical for the police agencies and department to make improving police-community relationship a top police priority. Policies should be developed that will strengthen the mutual trust between the police and the community. This relationship is critical because the police depend on information from the community to fight crime in the society.