preview

Income Statement Presentation of Unusual Loss

Decent Essays

Accounting 301
June 9, 2014

Ethics Case 4 -7
Income statement presentation of unusual loss

Financial statements are very important for many participants in the financing reporting process. High-quality financing reporting is necessary to investors and creditors in decision-making process. Their decisions and judgments depend on accuracy of information presented in those statements. For example, investors try to predict future performance based on the company’s current earnings. They want to invest in a company that is profitable. Misleading information in financial statements can have a negative impact on their decision. Unfortunately, some managers try to manipulate financial statement in order to achieve desired outcomes. …show more content…

Before the company controller, Jim Dietz, decides to include the product recall under the extraordinary items, he has to determine whether this event is extraordinary or not because including the recall in the extraordinary item could misinform the investors. Jim Dietz says that recalls do occur in their industry but they have never had a recall of this magnitude. The Cranor Corporation’s loss from the product recall, even though significant in amount, does not satisfy both concepts of unusual and infrequent occurrence. Recalls should be considered as a risk in operating business. Moreover, recalls can be disguise of management shortfall and affect the company credibility. The company suffered loss from a recall that resulted from operations. Consequently, it should be included in continuing operations and reported as a separate component of continuing operations.

The CEO and the company controller are faced with an ethical dilemma. Their bonuses are calculated based on the income from continuing operations. A conflict of interest exists. The decision of the executives is influenced by the possibility of personal gain. They personally profit from the decision to report the recall as an extraordinary item. Also, they might be misclassifying the recall expense transaction as extraordinary in order to improve the results of continuing operations.

Reporting extraordinary items as a separate section of

Get Access