For my research project, I plan to examine how news coverage of missing and murdered Indigenous has shifted as a result of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission. Consequently, I conducted a literature review that was focused on the disproportionate levels of violence that Indigenous women in Canada face. More specifically, I was interested in the connection between news coverage, the historical and ongoing legacies of white settler colonialism, and the connection to Indigenous women’s violence. Within this literature review, a few things were startlingly clear. 1) Indigenous women’s voices about their own levels of violence are missing from the academic dialogue about this issue. 2) The ongoing and historical violence that settler colonialism …show more content…
Despite the fact that researchers have examined news coverage, the Indian Act and the historical legacies of white settler colonialism, very few addressed Indigenous resurgence movements. Many Indigenous communities do not rely on the state to protect them because they know that the police do not always in the best interests of these communities. Instead, they have created their methods of protecting their communities. These methods are within the purview of a greater Indigenous resurgence project that is occurring on Turtle Island. Therefore, how can we contextualize the role of a National Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Indigenous women with subsequent Indigenous resurgence movements that no longer rely on the state for their protection? Furthermore, very little research examined the efficacy of a National Inquiry despite decades of advocating for one. Is the National Inquiry even a relevant step forward if the ultimate aim to decolonize? Can the aims of decolonization and state participation in the condemnation of Indigenous violence be …show more content…
This research is often done by settlers, who fails to clearly communicate the complexities that exist in Indigenous feminisms. There is a clear lack of Indigenous voices within this field of scholarship, which means that this scholarship lacks experiential knowledge. Furthermore, the discussions about specific women’s cases, notably that of Cindy Gladue and Tina Fontaine, has a tendency to reproduce the idea of Indigenous women as a spectacle even when the author is critiquing those very same power dynamics. These women’s violence is presented in graphic detail and recreates them as spectacles rather than serving to humanize
Wayne Yang in “Decolonization Is Not a Metaphor,” this project also takes into consideration the Native feminist work done by Lindsay Nixon which emphasizes a necessitate to not hierarchically dichotomizes land work and relational work and to understand praxis which focuses on harm reduction to not necessarily constitute decolonization, but to still possess value as it offers a way of surviving. In responding to Billy Ray Belcourt’s call for Indigenous studies to attune itself to the small worlds of the ordinary, this paper articulates the possible ways in which trauma-focuses therapy might provide decentralized ways for Black and Indigenous communities to not only grapple with their own trauma, but assist those in their communities with trauma as well. While this work may not be properly decolonizing insofar as it, as a practice, does not look towards land repatriation, it certainly enables decolonizing work insofar as the traumas endured by activists in both Indigenous and Black struggles like Standing Rock or #BlackLivesMatter need to be addressed in full or else we risk debilitating those who are constantly on the front lines of violence. Not only this however, but our own communities carry with them histories of trauma regardless of direct confrontation with violence. In fact, as David Marriott has articulated, it is of the utmost importance that we understand that it is the afterwardness of
For the past forty years, women have been reported murdered or missing along the highway 16 corridor in Northern British Columbia. The 724- kilometer stretch of road from Prince George to Prince Rupert was given the name “the highway of tears”. In the documentary Highway of Tears by Matt Smiley, the focus of the documentary was to set out and find the root cause of the disappearances and murders and to shed light on the real issue of violence against women and systematic racism in the justice system. The documentary looks at true stories of women who have gone missing or have been murdered along the highway of tears. The documentary focuses on how the highway of tears is the core of a much larger problem of how the indigenous population has been treated since colonialism. (Smiley, 2015) This essay will focus on summarizing the documentary, showing the correlation between the injustice the women and their families have faced and the mainstream and critical theories of victimization, and provide a critical reflection.
Charlie Angus was elected as a Member of Parliament in 2004, a role which took him to the Forgotten Children of Attawapiskat. It was his experiences prompted him to write his book, Children of the Broken Treaty: Canada’s Lost Promise and one Girl’s Dream, which tells the story of Indigenous persons of Canada’s struggles, including treaty rights, residential schools, as well as the fight for education and safe housing. The book provides a challenge to many common assumptions, and it also explores many themes which are used to explain the events which have shaped Canadian culture and policies. Angus begins his book by touching on some of the original treaties signed between the first Canadian government and the members of the bands that are indigenous to the land. One of these was Treaty 9, which promised education for Indigenous children. The book then developed into the foundation of residential schools, and the horrors that are endured there. In addition to the horrendous amounts of verbal, physical and sexual abuse which took place in these schools, the students who attended these institutions faced the mass genocide of their culture, as the unspoken purpose of these schools was “to kill the Indian in the child” (Angus, 2015, p. 14). The beginning of the book, while very dark, provides an honest introduction to some of the themes that can be spotted throughout the book, and history itself. The three themes that primarily stood out to me as a reader were: cultural
(Walker, 2015) Yet with great concern, her unfortunate story never made national headlines. As Walker writes, Leah Anderson's death adds one more name to the RCMP's list of 225 unsolved cases of missing and murdered indigenous women and girls across the country [...] and even two years after her death, there hasn't been a single arrest. "Who could have done this? Do I see this person? Is he around here?" are just a few of the many unanswered questions asked by Myra Anderson, the aunt of the deceased. With the rise of horrific incidences as such, the question of a woman’s safety and security rise to prominence as fear takes over, yet who do we turn to for answers? Neither the government officials nor the RCMP have definite answers as to why we heed and pay more attention to one kind of body but not the other, as to why and how we have deemed and distinguished one body more important than the other… one life more valuable than the other? This issue is of high importance as the Aboriginal population is being discriminated against, which has been a continuation from the attack of Colonialism which enslaved and enforced thousands to assimilate into a more ‘civilized’ western culture. The on-going marginalization and bigotry has dug the whole even deeper as the "vulnerability and societal disinterest has placed Aboriginal women at higher risk for violence in all forms" (Pearce, 2013). What has fallen to the blind side of the greater public eye is the substantial number of cases that have gone unsolved and it is in this aspect that more consideration and resolution is
The film Highway of Tears brought to light many issues faced by Indigenous persons however, its main focus was the missing and murdered women found along Highway 16 in Northern British Columbia. Majority of the women who are missing as well as those who were murdered are Indigenous women. This film displayed that although there are ways to prevent and possibly end the violence against Aboriginal women, no action was being taken by police or other government agents to do so. It was discussed how this as well as other wrongs done to Indigenous persons and communities, is a result of past and present colonialism.
We are learning that when genuine 'Indigenous' Justice is hiding under the cloak of Western paradigms, we continue to see the rising population of Indigenous peoples--especially Indigenous women--in prisons. Our programs and rehabilitative initiatives remain under Western paradigms, even when painted with the brush of 'restorative' or 'indigenous'
In April 1995 Pamela George, an Ojibway women, was brutally murdered in Saskatchewan. Her murderers Steven Kummerfield and Alex Ternowetsky, young middle-class white men, were convicted of manslaughter and sentenced to merely six and a half years in prison. George’s story is one of the many Indigenous women who have been murdered or missing over the past years. There are over 580 cases of missing and murdered Indigenous women, close to half are put aside and left unsolved. Only 53% of these cases have lead to charges of homicide (Klement 8). Drastically, statistics indicate that Aboriginals are faced with more hardships throughout their life compared to the average Canadian. Indigenous groups, particularly women, suffer from a lower rate of education, higher suicide rates and an array of health risks. This paper will examine the role settler colonization history has played in perpetuating conditions for violence to indigenous women, many of which are still experienced today. This will be accomplished by first assessing the history of settler colonization and its negative repercussions. Secondly, it will use Sherene Razak’s concept of “spatial segregation,” to illustrate how state institutions have facilitated violence through space, race and the law. Lastly, this paper will use evidence from the film “Finding Dawn” to further demonstrate how violence towards indigenous women is institutionally produced.
In Canada, there has been an on going concern in the matter of missing and murdered Indigenous women. Although many First nations individuals have many barriers placed upon them by society, the government and many other institutions. Indigenous women face many of these barriers very harshly. Aboriginal women are vulnerable to many different forms of abuse because of not only being female but also due to issues such as poverty. First nations citizens have been faced with extreme difficulties throughout every aspect of their lives. These difficulties ultimately include the discrimination they face daily from police services, lack of resources in order to assist their need, etc. There have been many problems which have lead up to the social problem of missing and murdered Indigenous women which include the historical upbringing of our First nations population, and unfortunately through recent factors as well. Theories like the feminist theory assist in the debunking of this problem and give us a brief insight into the situation. To this day, the very serious issue of missing and murdered Indigenous women is a key issue, which has been left with many cases unsolved. This in part clearly demonstrates the lack of efforts put in place by Canadian police in order to combat this problem. A case, which raised serious problems in North America, is the case of Lisa, a young Metis woman who at the age of fifteen disappeared walking home from a shopping trip, to which she was never found.
In the article “Domestic violence against indigenous women is everybody’s problem” domestic violence is depicted as a serious social problem that involves “unspeakable acts of violence” that leaves victims experiencing fear and despair (Taylor 2014). More specifically, the social construction of domestic violence will be discussed with an emphasis on Aboriginal women and a typology of intimate partner violence. The social construction of domestic violence has serious implications for victims of domestic abuse because there is a failure to address the processes that perpetuate the violence. Instead, domestic violence is addressed through the illusion of social support. What is evident is that domestic violence is a social problem that requires comprehensive services, particularly for indigenous women, to address the complexity of the interaction between the individual’s social location and the causes that lead to the violence.
Aboriginal persons in Canada have been facing oppression ever since colonization began. Even when Canada gained independence from the British Empire, the oppression continued and still goes on today. One major contributing factor to the oppression of Aboriginal people in Canada is the actions taken by the Government. The Government of Canada has in fact mistreated and found to be partaking in wrongdoing when dealing with the Aboriginal population in this country. With this ugly truth being revealed, the Truth and Reconciliation Commission had to be tasked with discovering and revealing past wrongdoing by a government in the hope of resolving conflict left over from the past. (cite)
Women no matter where they are in the world are too often victims of violence. They face higher rates than men both if it is sexual assault, stalking, or severe spousal abuse and usually the results are that women will end up extremely injured or dead. With young women suffering the highest rates of violence, Aboriginal women in particular face an increased risk of violence compared to non-Aboriginal women. Aboriginal women in Canada are three times more likely to experience crucial and severe violence compared to non-Aboriginal women. Most of these women end up missing and murdered. The predicaments of missing and murdered Aboriginal women has brought tremendous pain and suffering in homes, in families and throughout Aboriginal communities. Many sources and factors have contributed to hindering solving this issue. Media and discrimination have long been known to have played a huge role in this tragedy.
Barker, J. (2008). Gender, Sovereignty, Rights: Native Women's Activism against Social Inequality and Violence in Canada. American Quarterly, 60(2), 8. Retrieved fro m http://search.Proquest.com.Ez proxy.library.yorku.ca/docview/61688929?Acc ountid=15182.
Imagine a normal day. You wake up, you get ready, you probably see your mom, wife or sister. You say goodbye and head on your way. Once home, you sit down with them and talk about your day. When sad they comfort you, they love, support, care for you. Now imagine you wake up one day and they have disappeared without a trace. Gone. You are heartbroken. This is a sad reality for many Indigenous families, many women are vanishing without a trace. Between 1200-4000 Indigenous women have been missing or murdered in the last 30 years. These women are often targeted and treated as being worthless leading to little support from police and the public. After being immersed into this issue I learned lots, but I was left feeling sad,
Throughout history, women have been the victims of oppression in society. In specific, Aboriginal women have suffered through racism, sexism, domestic violence, and over-representation. Through the implementation of the Indian Act, Aboriginal women have been forced to abandon their culture in order to assimilate into Canadian society. The effects of colonization has changed the way Aboriginal women are treated; emotionally and physically, and therefore are the source of oppression today.
Each individual makes up the society as it is, and various characteristics and beliefs makes up an individual. Although, individual lives together with a variety of personal ideologies, emotions, cultures, and rituals, they all differentiate one person from the other making up one’s own identity. This identity makes up who one is inside and out, their behaviour, actions, and words comes from their own practices and values. However, the profound history of Indigenous people raises question in the present about their identities. Who are they really? Do we as the non-native people judge them from the outside or the inside? Regardless of whether the society or the government were involved in their lives, they faced discrimination in every