preview

Is Cloning Morally Wrong

Decent Essays

From Star Wars to the Jurassic Park movies cloning has always been a science fiction story that was light years ahead of us. But with recent evidence and research to clone living organisms, the far away fantasies of cloning we have been dreaming about for many years is rapidly becoming a reality, even faster than we think. Twenty years ago, in 1997, Dolly the Sheep was the first successful clone to be produced from an adult mammal. In the article “The Coming of Clones” American Scientists announced in 2013 that they had for the first time successfully obtained stem cells from cloned human embryos (the building blocks of cloning life). Due to this announcement and the cloning of Dolly, cloning has become a debatable topic that has both negative …show more content…

On September 27th, 2004 the The Roman Catholic Church announced their teaching on cloning. The Vatican explains that a cloned human is human but has no basis in claiming they are unique from anyone else on the planet. In the article “Document Of the Holy See On Human Cloning” the church says, In the end, a clone is still a human so as a church we must still treat them with dignity. But knowing the society of the world the clone will be treated as if they were replaceable at any time. Humans are naturally unique but when you create a clone, the clone, and even the person being used to make a copy, will no longer have the basis to say they are physically unique and different from anyone else in the world (“Document of the Holy See…” 1). When we clone we are creating an exact physical duplicate. Emotionally and spiritually the clone, and the one being cloned, are not the same person. What the Vatican is concerned about is not that the clone was not created traditionally (one Man and one Woman), but how the clone will be treated in the real world. The church announced that they will always welcome and respect a clone because it is still human, but the world will not. Throughout the clones life, it will be treated with less dignity and many people will have the impression that the clone is replaceable. Even though this clone is human many in society will not always treat a clone in a human way. The Roman Catholics are not the only ones teaching their views on cloning. While many other countries have banned human cloning, the country of Israel continues to wrestle with this issue. Many Jewish leaders have entered the debate so they turned to their religion. Shlomo Brody the author of “Does Jewish Law Support Genetic Cloning?” says that “according to Nahmanides, cloning challenges the perfections of God’s creations and presumes God-like powers” (Brody 2). Essentially cloning

Get Access