Solitary Confinement: A Utilitarian’s Perspective
The United States prison system has many flaws that need to be addressed but for the sake of the length of this essay I will only address one. Solitary confinement is the practice of locking inmates in cells roughly six foot by nine foot for twenty-two to twenty-four hours a day. These cells have a bed, toilet, and sink within them and, for the most part, are windowless. Inmates in solitary confinement are allowed zero human interaction other than their escort by two armed guards to their “yard” activity one hour a day. In this essay, I will show that solitary confinement is immoral when judged by John Stuart Mills account of utilitarianism. I will discuss three factors of the practice that
…show more content…
Once an inmate is place on solitary confinement, the only social interaction they have is with two armed guards as they are escorted to the “yard” or their one hour of activity. I emphasize “yard” because the area for activity for inmates under isolation is hardly able to be considered a yard. It is barely bigger than their cell and many times it is completely enclosed with fencing from the walls to the ceiling. This isolation from humans and the outside world has sever effects on inmates. Prisoners in solitary confinement have increased rates of self mutilation and suicide. According to Solitary Watch: Psychological Effects of Solitary Confinement, in 2005 forty-four prisoners in the California prison system committed suicide, 70% of whom were in solitary confinement. The study continues in 2007 with examination of attempted suicide in the prison system and “identified solitary confinement as a major factor in suicidal ideation and suicide attempts.” (Solitary Watch 1) Since we are causing severe mental illness in inmates AND increasing their violent inhibitions the net pleasure of all those involved is drastically reduced. Housing an inmate in isolation comes at a drastic cost to their mental being and to the well being of those around them when released but at what fiscal …show more content…
According to the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitations the cost of housing an inmate in solitary confinement is nearly double the cost of housing a level one inmate. “In 2010-2011 it cost $43,640 to house a level one inmate and a staggering $70,641 to house an inmate in solitary confinement at Pelican Bay.” (CDCR 2) These cost do not include the cost of training guards to handle maximum security inmates nor does it include the cost of hourly wages for the guards. These figures also do not include the cost of construction of the maximum security cells. For example, “Wisconsin’s Boscobel supermax facility was built to house 500 people at a cost of $47. million (in 1990 dollars), or over $95,000 per bed.” (solitary watch) John Stuart Mill contentd that the greatest utility is not measured individually but collectively; “… the utilitarian standard; for that standard is not the agent’s own greatest happiness, but the greatest amount of happiness altogether.” (Mill 11) Thus, the happiness of all citizens must be collectively judged. Consequently, the net pleasure of all citizens is decreased by the immense cost of isolation. Partially due to the cost factor alone and partially due to the cost factor with the outcomes
Many researchers have found that long periods of time in solitary confinement can have negative mental effects on inmates. This is due to long-term confinement because it consists of not only prolonged deprivation of social interaction but also sensory deprivation (Haney, 2003). Medical ethics are also in question about the effects of long term confinement. Medical professionals have to handle a particularly difficult situation because they are required to provide medical assistance to these inmates that may be facing psychological issues. This is a problem because medical professionals are aware that solitary confinement has negative effects on the well-being and mental state of these individuals (Shalev, 2011).
Inmates have been placed here for both short and long term sentences. Segregation has a significant impact on inmates with preexisting mental illnesses. According to Arrigo and Bullock?s (2008) research, ?the extreme isolation that was characteristics of the early prisons?ultimately resulted in serious physical and psychological consequences for convicts.? The SHU has become the way prisons control troublesome inmates. Solitary inmates are only out of their cells for weekly showers and recreation time, but they are still heavily restrained. These inmates have no contact with the general population including dining and religious gatherings. This method of isolation leaves no remove for communication with other
Greg Dobbs is a journalist, professional public speaker, and ABC News correspondent. Dobbs argues in agreeance of keeping solitary confinements in the prison systems for way of punishment. He first talks about Rick Raemisch’s, Department of Correction boss, experience as he stayed in solitary confinement for twenty hours at the Colorado Prison. Dobbs quoted Raemisch when he said, “I sat with my mind”. Raemisch brought a lot of attention to the evil side of solitary confinement says Dobbs. He then reminds the reader that convicted criminals
Four concrete walls, a steel bed, and a sink to soak the unclean clothes in as well as an insignificantly compact restroom. Welcome to solitary confinement where the lights always stay on and there’s always room for just one, you. When we think about solitary confinement we probably think of a killer or rapist getting what they deserve. What we don’t see is another human life being psychologically destroyed. Some of these prisoners have been in solitary confinement from a couple of years to decades. It is true that these are not honorable or peace keeping men, but a human life being tortured by solitude is a torture no one deserves.
There are many reasons why solitary is so cost heavy, but one of the main reasons is the construction of supermax facilities (PAYING).These specially made cells have to have advanced technology. Because of these additions, solitary confident cells can cost almost two to three times more than normal prison cells (PAYING). Another major reason solitary costs so much is the need for more staff. Inmates in solitary must be monitored and escorted anytime they leave their cell. Therefore prisons must hire extra staff. These staff must also be specially trained. Many duties that are usually done by inmates, such as cooking and cleaning, have to be done by paid staff (PAYING). In Pelican Bay in California, it is estimated that the average cost to hold a prisoner is $77,740. Who is paying to hold all these prisoners in solitary? Taxpayers “pay an additional $175
Solitary confinement has had a long history in the American prison system. America is the first country to adapt solitary confinement into the prison regiment. Pennsylvania had the first special housing units for inmates or “SHU”. When Europeans came to America to look at the new model for prisons in Pennsylvania they wrote reports describing to the European parliament on how prisoners were treated like caged animals. Many of them quickly realized that this was not what prisons were set out to accomplish. The purpose of a prison is to rehabilitate criminals and bring them back into society as an individual that has the best mental tools and skills to make their respective communities better. Putting inmates in solitary confinement for more than 48 hours can only lead to awful emotional pain and mental problems which can result in self-destructive behavior to regain the self-control that is being deprived through this process of isolation and expulsion.
There is a loss of privacy for the prisoner, even though they are all alone in the cell, guards are constantly watching them. They are there watching every move they make. It is often argued that solitary confinement creates a loss of freedom because the prisoner is already taken away from society, but then also isolated again in prison. The idea of being surrounded by four walls for 23 hours of the day is frightening. Therefore, many prisoners develop suicidal thoughts, personality disorders, and mental illnesses such depression, anxiety, paranoia, bipolar, schizophrenia, and claustrophobia (ConnectUS, 2015). It can also be stated that the purpose of solitary confinement is often not effective because instead of having someone there to help them process what they did, they are isolated. Prisoners in confinement simply end up just waiting for time to pass by instead of thinking about their
Inmates currently in solitary confinement reach numbers as high as 100,000 and this includes juveniles and people with mental illness. Stuart Grassin, a board-certified psychiatrist and a former faculty member at Harvard Medical School, has interviewed hundreds of prisoners in solitary confinement. In one study, he found that roughly a third of solitary inmates were “actively psychotic and/or actually suicidal.” Suicide is a huge concern with solitary confinement, in one study of California’s prison system, researchers found that prisoners in solitary confinement accounted for nearly half of all suicides. Within the confined walls of your segregation prison cell I can see how over time it would seem like the only way out of your cell is to take your own life.
According to “Solitary Confinement: Common Misconceptions and Emerging Safe Alternatives” by Alison Shames, Jessa Wilcox, and Ram Subramanian on the Vera Institute of Justice, solitary confinement is often sentenced to “fulfill a prison’s or jail’s top priority: the safety of its staff and the incarcerated people under their care.” (Shames, Wilcox, & Subramanian, 2015). However, most inmates that are placed in solitary confinement are
Over the last couple of decades, prison systems have adopted the use of solitary confinement as a means of punishment and have progressively depended on it to help maintain obedience and discipline inside the prison structure. Solitary confinement is a form of incarceration in which a prisoner is isolated in a cell for multiple hours, days, or weeks with limited to no human contact. According to the American Civil Liberties Union, the United States represents only 5% of the world's population yet houses 20% of the world’s prisoners (ACLU). Two of the biggest problems with our modern day criminal justice system is the overwhelming number of people that are incarcerated in the United States and the overwhelming number of convicts who return
While solitary confinement is one of the most effective ways of keeping todays prisoners from conflict and communication, it is also the most detrimental to their health. According to NPR the reason for most solitary confinement units in America “is to control the prison gangs (NPR, 2011).” But that is not always the case. Sometimes putting a gang member in solitary reduces the shock and awe effect that it is supposed to have, when they start losing their minds. The prisoners kept in solitary confinement show more psychotic symptoms than that of a normal prisoner, including a higher suicide rate. Once a prisoner’s mental capacity to understand why he is in prison and why he is being punished is gone, there is no reason to keep said
Solitary confinement is viewed as one of the best punishments for prisoners’ bad behavior in order to protect the rest of the inmates. Solitary confinement has proven to have the reverse effects in terms of a person’s psychological state. Solitary confinement means that the prisoners do not have normal stimulus and human communication which has its toll on the prisoners. Prisoners who are in solitary confinement only have themselves and the acoustics of their squared prison cell which tends to drive many to hallucinate, act violently, or commit suicide.
Solitary Confinement can actually cause mental health issues. People can literally go insane because of no interaction with people and being in isolation all the time. Some people get so bad that they have to be take and put in a straight jacket in a padded room. For 23 hours a day inmates are kept in a room a little smaller than a horse stable, and the only time they have to get out is when it’s time for them to be outside. Some prisons don’t even do that. All they do is give them food through a little whole in the door. (Front
But the true problems comes when it comes to mental instability for humans are social animals and a lack of can lead to bad things . For instance “Prisoners subject to solitary confinement became violently insane; others committed suicide.” said the US Supreme court in 1890. Solitary confinement had been ruining people's minds for a long time for example in solitary confinement people tend to fall in depression, see many hallucination and forget how to tell time properly. But solitary confinement does protect the prisoners as stated before.
Since the early 1800s, the United States has relied on a method of punishment barely known to any other country, solitary confinement (Cole). Despite this method once being thought of as the breakthrough in the prison system, history has proved differently. Solitary confinement was once used in a short period of time to fix a prisoners behavior, but is now used as a long term method that shows to prove absolutely nothing. Spending 22-24 hours a day in a small room containing practically nothing has proved to fix nothing in a person except further insanity. One cannot rid himself of insanity in a room that causes them to go insane. Solitary confinement is a flawed and unnecessary method of punishment that should be prohibited in the prison