preview

Jonathon Swift Misogyny

Decent Essays

Jonathon Swift steps into risky territory as he addresses misogyny in the invasive, satirical way he does in his (year) controversial poem The Lady’s Dressing Room. Perhaps not surprisingly, Lady Montagu takes advantage of her literary pull and writes a satirical response, clearly offended by the misogynist message she assumed the poem to have. While Swift’s poem gives a significant amount of evidence to justify Montagu’s retort, there is perhaps a deeper amount of evidence that suggests she missed Swift’s point. Each poem has a satiric closure at its end, but Swift’s choice of words lean towards a position of commentary on misogyny rather than a position supporting it. In contrast, the last line of Montagu’s poem pins Swift down as a staunch …show more content…

After their beauty has been brought to life from the dung in which they were planted in, women become “gaudy tulips” (). Understandably, one can see how Lady Montagu may have danced over this image with the stench lingering from the final word she read. Had she taken the time to analyze this phrase, she may not have been so harsh in her action. To begin, one must start with “gaudy,” simply because of its modern connotation to mean something is showy, or tasteless in its ornateness. In the context of this poem, this word did not have such a connotation, so as it appears to mean, simply, “luxurious” (Oxford English Dictionary). Keeping this is in mind as one looks at the context of the tulip at this time, it is clear that this simple comparison to a flower actually as much more meaning to it than at first glance. Just before swift’s time the tulip caused a financial crisis because of how desired it was (Donatini). This being said, the tulip had not only visual beauty but historical extravagance. Knowing the background on both “gaudy” and “tulip,” it is easy to see that Lady Montagu failed to see the rich beauty Swift truly was emphasizing that is found within women, a beauty that is truly dependent upon, not despite, their “dung-like” qualities. [This imagery paints an incredible picture of the idea that beauty can, and traditionally does, come from forth from unexpected places. This is true especially when one takes the image further in terms of the seed of the tulip having contained within it all the beauty it will possess when it becomes a full flower, thus needing the rich “dung” to encourage that beauty to blossom.] It is evident that Montagu missed all this image has to offer a woman judging by the harsh, though clever, final line in her poetic

Get Access