preview

Lab-Cultured Meat

Decent Essays

Let’s Get to the Meat of the Discussion When most people think about a juicy, flavor filled hamburger – the warm buns, melted cheese; ice cold lettuce and tomato; sweet pickle; and the perfect, equal amounts of both ketchup and mustard – they are likely reminded of grilling outside at a BBQ or grabbing a bite to eat at famous burger shops like Fuddruckers or Five Guys. However, the idea of the “All American Hamburger” has been changed in the eyes of some scientists and those who prefer not to eat meat. Researchers and developers have come up with a way to grow lab-cultured meat by vitro methods. This method of producing meat has raised concerns and has been a growing topic of discussion based of the unnaturalness and potential health risks …show more content…

Some include still using fossil fuels, the lost taste of real meat, potentially damaging the recovering economy, and potentially causing issues within three popular religions in the United States of America. All of the reasons that are used to justify that making fake meat is the right thing to do can be backed by how it should not be done. For example, molecular biologist Margaret Mellon from the Union of Concerned Scientists brings up points about how all of the technology that is used to make the cultured cells is actually bad for the environment. She …show more content…

Considering three big religions that are prominent across the United States, Jewish, Muslim, and Christianity, all give feedback on what they consider to be right or wrong regarding if they can or should eat the real meat. In the Jewish religion, there is discussion over whether the fake meat will be considered Kosher. Rabbi Joshua Strulowitz of the West Side Institutional Synagogue in New York stated, “‘The animal would need to be slaughtered according to Jewish law before harvesting the cells because meat from a live animal is not Kosher.’” (Fox). In the Jewish sense, the animal would need to be killed anyways in order for the people of its religion to participate in the fake meat experiment so it is pointless. Regarding Muslim religion, the production of the in vitro meat would have to meet the standards under halal. According to the Oxford English Dictionary, halal is defined as “the act of killing an animal in the matter prescribed by Muslim law” (OED). Dr. Abdul Qahir Qamar, Director of Fatwas and Sharia rulings at the International Islamic Fiqh Academy, an affiliate of the Organization of the Islamic Conference based in Saudi Arabia

Get Access