preview

Learning Difficulty And Learner Identity: A Symbiotic Relationship By Eliana Hirano (2009)

Decent Essays

This is a review paper for the article “Learning difficulty and learner identity: a symbiotic relationship” by Eliana Hirano (2009). In this paper I will analyze the findings in the study, the way it was conducted, the arguments made by the author, and also the writing style of Hirano. I will give my honest opinion as a reader, as a learner and also based on my short experience as a language teacher. Hirano´s article is based on the strong belief of the importance of the learner´s identity role in order to learn a language. The author describes step by step her journey to help jr. change his self-concept as a learner. The results were favorable; nevertheless I believe this is a very extreme technique that cannot be conducted by everyone. I also believe there could be other ways of helping the student lowering the amount of work for the teacher. The article starts with a brief introduction, in which the author explains how the study was conducted and what tools were used to collect data; however these tools are never shown in the article. I think it would be interesting if instead of only describing what they used or …show more content…

I was amazed by the number of different resources used to collect data, as well as the time and effort she put for this study and specially to help Junior.
I enjoyed a lot reading this article; it was my first approach to the ‘learning identity’ concept, however now that I have read other articles I would say the author of this article could have added more information to her literature review, as well as examine other theories or models to apply on her research. Taylor’s (2010) theoretical framework focuses on the private self, public selves, ideal self, and imposed selves; giving a greater dimension to the learner identity

Get Access