This is a review paper for the article “Learning difficulty and learner identity: a symbiotic relationship” by Eliana Hirano (2009). In this paper I will analyze the findings in the study, the way it was conducted, the arguments made by the author, and also the writing style of Hirano. I will give my honest opinion as a reader, as a learner and also based on my short experience as a language teacher. Hirano´s article is based on the strong belief of the importance of the learner´s identity role in order to learn a language. The author describes step by step her journey to help jr. change his self-concept as a learner. The results were favorable; nevertheless I believe this is a very extreme technique that cannot be conducted by everyone. I also believe there could be other ways of helping the student lowering the amount of work for the teacher. The article starts with a brief introduction, in which the author explains how the study was conducted and what tools were used to collect data; however these tools are never shown in the article. I think it would be interesting if instead of only describing what they used or …show more content…
I was amazed by the number of different resources used to collect data, as well as the time and effort she put for this study and specially to help Junior.
I enjoyed a lot reading this article; it was my first approach to the ‘learning identity’ concept, however now that I have read other articles I would say the author of this article could have added more information to her literature review, as well as examine other theories or models to apply on her research. Taylor’s (2010) theoretical framework focuses on the private self, public selves, ideal self, and imposed selves; giving a greater dimension to the learner identity
Purpose: To highlight the difficulties students have at school and at home when it comes down to learning a language which they aren’t acquainted to and the consequences of such, depending on their social background.
The student identity is the identity one builds throughout the years of middle school through college where standardized curriculum shapes everyone individually. On the other hand, a person’s learning identity has to do with the way they learn to evolve mentally and spans a person’s lifespan. My student identity right now can be described as a VCU undergrad student majoring in biology as a pre-dental student. The factors that have shaped my student identity would be my personal interest in biology, quality of school I attended, teachers I’ve had even friends have shaped my student identity.
In the article “Identity as an Analytical Lens for Research in Education” James Paul Gee builds up his thesis based on the idea of a person ‘being’ identified in a certain setting, can change at every instant, and in every context, and is controversial and never static. Gee is trying to infer the idea that the dynamicity of one’s identity is very dependent on the reaction to a certain encounter in a particular circumstance.
Identity is what makes a person different from all other individuals. Throughout history it shows that people tend to conform to society's perception of who they should be when they don't take the time out to figure out who they are. Therefore, it is important for people to have a sense of who they are. In " The Lesson" by Toni Cade Bambara, it shows how the main character struggles to figure out her identity and how she sees herself.
Although bilingual education has some merit, avoiding the implementation of the more popular language of a community is detrimental to the incorporation of mostly you people in society and hinders their ability to develop a keen sense of identity. For example, "language gets learned as it gets used (7).” In other words, one masters the language as he speaks it. Speaking and language skills tend to sharpen if they are used regularly. Rodriguez argues that learning both languages and using them rather than leaving one begins to lead to a better sense of identity and freedom. But according to Rodriguez it makes one become insecure, growing up
Do you know how you learn about your identity? Is it through eExperiences or people in your life? According to dictanory.com identity means being a who or what as a person or a thing. For example I have an identity, and you have identity. Identity is a really important thing. Individuals learn about himself through the people in their lives.
Identity is defined as the characteristics that distinguish a particular person or group of people from others. Most people do not find their identities, until they have become older and more experienced in life. However, there are a few who discover themselves in a shorter amount of time. During life, humans will face some difficult decisions or situations that will help shape them into the individuals they are today, whether these difficulties be beneficial or harmful in the end. For example, death, guilt, love, anger, misunderstanding and many other emotions can contribute to the process of self-discovery.
As you go throughout life, it is not very common to stop and question your own personal identity, because you are just you, there does not seem like that much to it. But, in the philosophical world, this topic is one of the most popular things to look into and try to understand. Surprisingly, the idea of personal identity is not as simple as it seems. Many philosophers seem to question if personal identity even exists, and if they do believe it exists, how exactly? In the most popular philosophical arguments, there are three theories of personal identity that stick out; psychological approach, ego theory, and bundle theory. These three theories discuss how personal identity can be identified, or if it even exists at all. There is no way to be one hundred percent positive that one of these theories is true, so there will be always be a mystery to personal identity. Even though we can never be sure, it is always interesting to look into each theory and discuss the possibilities to our own personal identity.
Thesis: how reading and viewing of different texts has broadened my understanding of the world and how identity is a virtual tool which can empower individuals to excel in one way or another.
The author developed a sense of self-concept as he found himself growing up with Spanish culture, which help him recall his early childhood. Growing up he’s hunger to learn Spanish and trying to speak Spanish with confidence. The author is hoping to break the barrier and could speak Spanish freely. The author’s cultural identities are built up from his life and school experiences. He attended daily tutoring session in school and needed special attention from teacher.
Identity is a socially and historically constructed concept. An individual learns about their own identity through interactions with family, peers, organizations, media, and educational institutions. Education and identity are two closely related topics. On average, most Americans will spend a fourth of their life in educational institutions. During this time period students are growing and maturing, but most importantly they are discovering themselves. Students realize their qualities, determine their morals, and establish their beliefs during this time of instruction. Undoubtedly, education forms and challenges a person’s identity throughout the years.
Identity is formed by the influence of various physical and psychological experiences that occurs throughout an individual’s life and reforms their identity. One’s identity is not made through a single event alone but through a series of events that changes it. Moreover, some events are more influential and powerful in the shaping of one 's identity. Identity, as defined by Merriam-Webster Dictionary, is “The qualities, beliefs, etc., that make a particular person or group different from others”. In "Project Classroom Makeover", by Cathy Davidson, the author highlights how students ' developed their identities through various cognitive thinking skills and the freedom to be creative. In "The Naked Citadel", by Susan Faludi, identities are shaped through traditions, rules, and obedience. However, it is not to say that character cannot be formed by both the use of intellectual abilities and long standing practices. The creation and reforming of our identity changes throughout an individual 's life because of the impact of creative thinking, traditions, and relationships.
This essay is a reflective essay on my learning development from a young age through to my current position as a University Student. I will be relating my learning development back to two theories of human development, Vygotstsky’s socio-cultural theory and Marcia’s version of Erikson’s theory of identity development. I will identify and discuss the challenge I have faced with my identity and how this has impacted on my development.
Correspondingly, the identity defined by Wenger (1998: 127) has five characterizations. According to him, we define who we are by participation and reification (negotiated experience), by the familiar and the unfamiliar (community membership), by where we have been and where we are going (learning trajectory), by the ways we reconcile our various forms of membership into one identity (nexus of multimembership), and by connecting the locality of practice to a broader context (a relation between the local and the global). Wenger’s definition of identity is relatively comprehensive in that it connects individuals in interaction, encompasses boundaries of communities and multiple identities in practice, and includes the past and the future, the
Identity is what evolves us, it is what makes us think the way we do, and act the way we act, in essence, a person’s identity is their everything. Identity separates us from everyone else, and while one may be very similar to another, there is no one who is exactly like you; someone who has experienced exactly what you have, feels the way you do about subjects, and reacts the same to the events and experiences you have had. This became prevalent to me as I read through many books, that everyone goes through the process of finding who they are. A prevalent theme throughout literature is the idea that over time one develops their identity through life over time, in contrast to being born with one identity and having the same