preview

Lgbtq Violations

Decent Essays

In a recent podcast regarding a transgender high school student being forced to change in the nurse’s office instead of in the locker room with other students addressed the controversy regarding the treatment of members of our society who identify as LGBTQ. Throughout the podcast, multiple individuals have voiced support for the school’s decision to isolate the transgender student when changing. Do to the opinions voiced in the podcast regarding this case, I realized that the treatment of the high school student is only one example of the existing discrimination towards those who identify as LGBTQ. As such, I intend to explore the controversy of LGBTQ and our obligations that we have as members of the same society. Throughout this paper, I …show more content…

As such, contractarianism provides a basis for why we have certain moral obligations for LGBTQ groups. However, the issue of whether or not our obligations are equal to other members of society arises, since there are cases in which other groups have been excluded from receiving the same moral obligations, such as those with different racial backgrounds, even though they are also members of our society. Due to the occurrence of other factors that justifies the idea of different obligations, such as in the case of racism, there is a vagueness as to which set of obligations one should uphold. Thus the idea of epistemicism “the view that there is an unknowable fact of the matter for every vague matter” (Epistemicism, paradox, and conditional obligation) is incurred since we are faced with the vagueness of which moral obligation we ought to apply when interacting with those that are LGBTQ. Under contractarianism, the concept of a “veil of ignorance” (page 199) assists in answering the question of what moral obligations to uphold. The “veil of ignorance” eliminates “all knowledge of your distinctive traits” (page 199) thus reducing our knowledge of others to the “basic human needs and wants” (page 199) .Thus contractarianism eliminates the vagueness that may occur due to Therefore, we should accept that our moral obligations to those who identify as LGBTQ are the same as the ones that we have towards other members of our

Get Access